Keep Space for Peace

Tom Unterrainer, END Info 50, November 2026 download pdf

Ken Coates warned in 2001 that plans surrounding the Bush Administration’s proposed ‘Full Spectrum Dominance’ were:

a drop from the ocean of intended future military investment, in which the American space planners seek to unleash an arsenal from science fiction.

He also warned of the “crashing through of Cold War Treaties” designed to prevent the full militarisation of space. Until 14 September 2026, no state had confirmed what seemed possible: that they had put offensive weaponry in orbit for the purpose of destroying other objects in space. Rather, the focus was on using the ‘space domain’ for ‘terrestrial’ operations: mainly ‘missile defence’. This has now changed with the Secretary of the US Air Force, Troy Meink’s, admission that the US “has space weapons in orbit.”

In his 1958 argument for not going to the moon (‘Let’s not go to the moon’), Bertrand Russell wrote:

I should wish to see a little more wisdom in the conduct of affairs on earth before we extend our strident and deadly disputes to other parts.

Russell would no doubt be disappointed with current developments on at least two counts: first, that our affairs on earth have not been conducted with more wisdom - quite the reverse, in fact - and second, that we now have confirmation that our “deadly disputes” have reached into orbit and will no doubt reach, before too long, the moon and beyond.

Of course, the ‘Space Race’ has been consistently entangled with military concerns and not only in the imaginations of science fiction writers. Was not Werner von Braun, the ‘father’ of the US space programme, also the Nazi responsible for the design of Hitler’s V-2 rockets that rained terror down on London, Antwerp and Liège at the end of WWII? Was it not the case that whilst the schoolboys of Kettering Grammar School were tracking Sputnik’s signals with the awe and wonder of creative minds, other minds were focussed on the possibilities of delivering nuclear warheads by rocket rather than satellites?

For all the awe, wonder and hope, the first ‘Space Race’ was shaped by the reality of superpower rivalry and by 1967 - two years before the first moon landing - the world concluded that measures should be taken to prevent the presence of weapons of mass destruction in space. As this dossier outlines, efforts to extend the Outer Space Treaty to exclude any and all weapons from space have made little progress, despite the consistent efforts of Russia and China in a succession of draft treaties. As the previous 49 issues END Info have documented, treaties on weapons of mass destruction, their regulation and non-proliferation have been serially undermined and sabotaged. Will the Outer Space Treaty survive the second ‘Space Race’?

The peace movement must insist that it should and support efforts to extend it by proscribing all space-based weaponry.

The view from the moon

The Outer Space Treaty involves rather more than banning WMDs. Its provisions include a clause that exempts ‘space and celestial bodies ... from national claims of ownership.’ This clause is rather problematic for those like the Adam Smith Institute, who in 2022 proposed that the moon be parcelled up by individual states and rented out to private companies. For their part, the Institute reckons the Outer Space Treaty to be a model of “outdated thinking” that we must move beyond. Similar lines of thinking no doubt lurk behind President Trump’s social media post of 6 September 2026, which declared “The moon is ours” alongside a Stars and Stripes flag. To date, there has been no confirmation as to whether Trump’s characteristically unsubtle claim constitutes official policy or not. A month later, on 8 October 2026, Trump re-announced plans (already contained in a 2025 executive order) to establish a permanent US base on the moon at a science and technology summit. The fact that in 2020 NASA announced support for the private extraction of resources from the moon is another highly relevant data point.

Why is it that some of the richest individuals on earth have invested so heavily in space technologies? Could there be something in it for them other than the ‘thrill’ of low-orbit travel or an unleashing of creative impulses in the name of scientific endeavour? Surely there is.

Fred Hoyle, the astronomer and science fiction writer, wrote in 1948 that “once a photograph of the Earth, taken from the outside, is available, a new idea as powerful as any in history will be let loose.” ‘Earthrise’, the famous view of earth from the moon, is credited with inspiring awe - a cognitive shift, even - in astronauts, named  the ‘overview effect’.

The view from the moon continues to inspire and to be profound. It inspired a generation to take the fragility of our planet seriously and to work towards its preservation. For others, it no doubt inspired the present scramble for the moon - all the better to escape the confines of earth and to extract resources where no human has extracted before.

In his posthumously published work, Der Blick vom Mond (The view from the moon), Günther Anders asks, “What use is the moon?” and answers: raw material. The ever-increasing presence of private companies - often entangled with government initiatives and often beneficiaries of government funding and ‘assistance’ - seems to substantiate Anders’s claim.

A view from the earth

Take the view from Goonhilly, on the Lizard peninsula in Cornwall, as an example. Goonhilly is home to an ‘earth communications station’ and was first populated with dishes and antennae in the early 1960s. The first, Antenna One (nicknamed “Arthur”), was erected to receive signals from the Telstar satellite. Through “Arthur” and subsequent additions, British television viewers were able to receive video transmissions and could watch Muhammed Ali fight and the moon landings. The site is especially valued as it stands on thousands of feet of metamorphic rock, which provides great stability and helps reduce signal interference.

By 2014 the site, previously owned and operated by British Telecom, was being operated by Goonhilly Earth Station Ltd. This company secured contracts with the European Space Agency and went into partnership with an ill-fated plan to turn nearby Newquay airport into a commercial space port. In 2018, Goonhilly began a collaboration with other organisations aimed at commercial moon landing operations. In 2024, the earth station involved with the first commercial moon landing - and the first moon landing since Apollo 17 in 1972. This moon landing was a project of the Texas-based Intuitive Machines company. This company now plans to purchase the Goonhilly facility.

Intuitive Machines is one of fourteen companies awarded $1.843 billion of contracts by ‘Space Systems Command’, the US Space Force’s (the ‘space wing’ of the US military) development, acquisition, launch and logistics command. The purpose of the contract is to develop ‘Space Domain Awareness’ capabilities under the Andromeda program.

Dave Webb of the Global Network Against Weapons and Nuclear Power in Space, describes Andromeda’s aims as enabling “predictive battlespace awareness that enables offensive and defensive space operations.” Goonhilly is now the world’s only fully commercial deep space station and will likely play a role in Andromeda.

Keep Space for Peace

It might be too late to ‘keep space for peace’ in all practical terms but we should aim to return peace to space. Why? Because the alternative is to permit the rampant militarisation and exploitation of not only earth orbit but of the moon and further reaches of the solar system. One driver of establishing a permanent presence on the moon is to more easily achieve travel to Mars, our nearest planetary neighbour. To achieve that, the moon will be raw material, just as earth is now raw material for those seeking to extract profit.

‘Let’s not go to the moon’, wrote Bertrand Russell with his still-pressing concerns about society on earth. The journey to the moon “was not the destination, but the starting point”, argued Anders: a “self-encounter with the Earth.” The most recent plans for lunar landings, the commercialisation and militarisation of the Heavens must be a further “self-encounter with the Earth” if we have any hope of long-term survival.