Protests against US nuclear weapons in Germany: Nuclear Sharing Must End!

From END Info 27 - Download

Despite the challenges presented by the Coronavirus, the nationwide campaign Büchel is everywhere! nuclear weapons free now and the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons (ICAN), succeeded in leading a broad political discussion about NATO’s dangerous nuclear deterrence policy regarding US nuclear weapons stationed in Büchel. We received prominent support from SPD parliamentary group leader Rolf Mützenich, who publicly raised the issue of ending Germany’s nuclear sharing arrangement. Our campaign group, Abolish nuclear weapons - start with us!, consisting of more than 70 peace movement organizations/groups, has increased pressure on the German government to withdraw the estimated 20 US nuclear bombs from Büchel. Germany must finally sign the 2017 Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons and become nuclear weapons-free, instead of implementing a planned nuclear “modernization”! Against this background, a “human chain” took place alongside the Büchel air base on September 5, 2021, exactly three weeks before the Bundestag elections (see further down in the text). Currently, the German parties of the so-called “traffic light coalition” (Social Democratic Party, Alliance90/the Greens, and Free Democratic Party) are holding coalition talks about their joint approach to nuclear weapons policy.

Political, Military & Industrial Background

Even though the Cold War ended 30 years ago, about 20 US nuclear bombs are still deployed at the German air force base Büchel in West Central Germany. German pilots are trained to take off with these bombs in their Tornado fighter jets when the order comes from the US president, through NATO, to drop them on their targets. This horrifying vision is part of the “nuclear sharing agreement” in NATO, with its nuclear deterrence policy, which includes a nuclear first-strike option.

These weapons of mass destruction – illegal and criminal under German, US, and international law – are scheduled to be replaced in the near future by expensive new, precision-guided nuclear weapons – the B61-12 – in a $10-$12 billion program of the US National Nuclear Security Administration’s nuclear weapons complex.

At least three US national laboratories (the Sandia and Los Alamos Labs in New Mexico, the Y-12 Complex in Tennessee) along with the Kansas City Plant in Missouri, are part of B61-12 construction, mainly through giant weapons contractors including Boeing (tailfin kit: $1.8 billion), Lockheed-Martin, Honeywell, and Bechtel. Around 400 B61-12 bombs are to be refurbished, at a cost of around $25 million per bomb (according to Hans Kristensen, director of the Nuclear Information Project at the Federation of American Scientists) making them more costly than if they were made of solid gold.

New developments in Büchel

Currently, Germany’s Büchel nuclear weapons base is to be expanded between June 2022 and January 2026 at a cost of $299 million (€259 million). This will be done at all six US nuclear weapons sites in Europe that are part of so-called “nuclear sharing” (Belgium, Netherlands, Italy, and Turkey). These construction measures serve to prepare for the deployment of the new B61-12 nuclear bombs, the production of which will begin in the United States at the end of this year. For these four years, Luftwaffe Squadron 33 with its Tornado fighter jets will move from Büchel to the Nörvenich military base near the city of Cologne. In the coming years, the old nuclear bombs (B61-3s and B61-4s) are to be replaced with the new B61-12s. At Büchel, the construction plans include expanding the runway, as well as modernizing the nuclear weapons infrastructure. For example, special containers in the aircraft hangars, where the approximately 20 bombs are stored, are to be renewed.

New nuclear weapon carrier fighter jets

For Germany’s new government, the decision on the acquisition of new nuclear weapons carrier aircraft from the US is pending, and is estimated to cost up to $9.248 billion, or €8 billion. Instead of buying the expensive and faulty US F-35 nuclear weapons carrier – as Belgium, the Netherlands and Italy plan to do – another US fighter jet is up for debate. Until 2040, when the EU’s Future Combat Air System (FCAS) nuclear weapons fighter is to be developed, Boeing’s F/A18, which can also land on US aircraft carriers, is currently favored as an interim solution. The German government wants to join forces with France and Spain to launch the new FCAS nuclear-capable multi-fighter aircraft. This new EU fighter would then perpetuate the controversial nuclear deterrent for decades between Germany and France. As a semi-autonomous weapons system networked with Eurodrones, the FCAS is expected to be operational from 2040 and would cost Germany alone about $578 billion or €500 billion euros. Buying new jets could be put off if the service life of the 40-year-old Tornado fighter jets are extended further.

Climate and nuclear carrier aircraft

Mildly put, the 45 new US F/A 18 fighter jets alone, which German Defense Minister Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer wants to buy for $10 billion for the nuclear bombs in Büchel, show her climate blindness. The current Tornado fighter jet has been deployed in the Eifel region since 1985. The CO2 pollution per flight hour of the Tornado fighter jet is 12,000 kg (12 t). The Büchel-based nuclear bomber pilots from Luftwaffe Squadron 33 reached their 200,000th Tornado flight hour in April 2019, after 34 years. They celebrated this in Büchel with media attention, which means that over 34 years, the old nuclear fighter jets alone have blown about 2.5 million tons of CO2 into our environment.

The cooperation with Fridays for Future is very important here, because military training flights, and air force “shows of force,” and nuclear attack rehearsals like Steadfast Noon, must also be included in the climate balance. These carbon blasts bear a considerable share of the responsibility for climate change and should be abolished.

Inside nuclear detonations, the nuclear chain reaction creates temperatures of 108 to 180 million degrees Fahrenheit (60 to 100 million degrees Celsius). This is about 10,000 to 20,000 times the surface temperature of our sun. The 500 above-ground nuclear tests, as well as the 1500 below-ground nuclear tests were detonated by states around the world. They share responsibility for global warming. The military belongs, especially with regard to nuclear weapons, within climate change negotiations and outlawed weapons of mass destruction.

Nuclear Weapons Ban Treaty

The entry into force of the international treaty banning nuclear weapons was celebrated around the world on January 22, 2021, and in Germany alone there were over 100 actions. The entry into force means that the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons is binding international law for any country ratifying or acceding to it. As ICAN Executive Director Beatrice Fihn said, “Nuclear weapons have always been immoral, now they are illegal.”

However, the provisions are binding only on signatory states, but this includes the signatory states that have not yet ratified the treaty: it applies to 86 states! The nuclear weapons states’ room for maneuver is thus becoming ever narrower. Some financial institutions have ethics rules against which they must now be measured if they finance corporations that produce nuclear weapons (parts, delivery and communications systems, etc.). Also, under the treaty, these weapons may no longer be produced in the 86 states that are party to the treaty.

The pressure on Germany’s government is constantly being increased by the Cities and Deputies Appeal and the organization of ‘Mayors for Peace’, so that Germany’s accession to the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons can finally take place. Together with ICAN, our member organizations are working hard for this: 646 parliamentarians, 171 of them members of the Bundestag, have already signed the appeal, which says in part: “As Members of Parliament, we vow to work towards the signing and ratification of this landmark treaty by our respective states, as we see the abolition of nuclear weapons as a high global public good and an essential step towards promoting the security and well-being of all peoples.” In total, 137 cities and four German states have joined the Cities Appeal to support the Treaty or call on the federal government to join it. Also, over 700 Mayors for Peace in Germany have joined the Mayors for Peace alliance calling for the abolition of nuclear weapons, the third biggest number of mayors in the world behind only Japan and Iran. Because of public interest – a poll shows that about 90% of public opinion is against these nukes – our united campaign includes well-established organizations like IPPNW, IALANA, German Fellowship of Reconciliation, Pax Christi, and DFG-VK.

Büchel could be the key for

nuclear disarmament

Our campaign shows that we are much stronger together when we focus on our united agreed goals: the fourth campaign started in 2016 with the name “20 weeks for 20 bombs.” Dozens of groups have traveled year after year to Büchel to protest directly at the base, which we call the “scene of crime.” Every year, religious leaders and bishops from different churches preach to as many as 1000 people at anti-nuclear gatherings near the base. Many group vigils and/or blockades take place at the base. Over the last several years Büchel has become a symbol of our civil disobedience/resistance to nuclear weapons. During the “20 weeks,” each group gets an introduction about our campaign Büchel is everywhere! nuclear weapons-free now. Many groups believe that besides lobbying and educational work, we also have to create pressure through nonviolent direct actions which uphold international laws prohibiting the planning and preparation of mass destruction (Nuremberg Principles).

Among the action groups is Nonviolent Action Abolish Nuclear Weapons (GAAA), which started the protests in Büchel 25 years ago. And since 2017, GAAA has coordinated an “international week” in July during the 20-week action presence. Among the internationals, we have had annual US delegations partly made up of peace activists working against US production of the new B61 nuclear bombs for Europe. Several “go-in” actions have resulted in court cases. On April 1, 2021, a formal appeal (of a conviction for a July 2018 “go-in” action) was filed by Stefanie Augustine and me with the Federal Constitutional Court (BGH) in Karlsruhe.

This was the 14th constitutional complaint filed this year, with almost 50 court cases of “go-in” actions in the last two years. So far, the Constitutional Court has refused to hear even one of the appeals complaints, ruling, among other things, that taking the cases would not be in the interest of the public. Again and again, all the lower courts have failed to recognize or apply international law, and they have refused to hear the testimony of the legal experts, e.g. Anabel Dwyer (US Adjunct Professor of Human Rights and Humanitarian Law at T. M. Cooley Law School). And this despite the fact that international law is superior to our German law.

In May 2021, the BGH wrote in reply to our complaint that it did not want to accept it, and the letter did not even give reasons for the rejection. This means that we have exhausted all possible legal remedies in Germany, so we are now at the beginning of November filing a complaint with the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR), also known as the Strasbourg Court. With our many well-coordinated proceedings; with individual partial successes and our public relations work, we are making it increasingly difficult for the courts to continue to justify their rejection of our defense of “crime prevention” under intentional law.

Human chain in Büchel sends a signal

In the run-up to the nation-wide Bundestag elections, a “human chain” last September 5, along the highway adjacent to the “Fliegerhorst Büchel” nuclear weapons base, brought together about 800 people of the peace movement. Thus, a clear message was sent to the parties from the civilian population that the new UN nuclear weapons ban treaty must be ratified by Germany, the US nuclear weapons must be withdrawn, and the deployment of the new B61-12 bombs must be halted.

Despite major restrictions due to Corona and the rail strike, more than 40 carrier circle groups of the nationwide campaign Büchel is everywhere! nuclear weapons free now arrived in city buses or cars. In bright sunshine, many peace activists met for the first time after a month-long Corona break, the reunion creating a great mood along the “human chain.” The musical resisters, Lebenslaute, sang songs, dozens carried banners, and from cars there was benevolent honking and waving. Afterwards, an exciting program of speeches – which above all opened up the European perspective – energized the participants at the rally square at the air base’s main gate.

In my remarks, I drew attention to the current development of nuclear armaments in Büchel on behalf of our campaign, and pointed out the real threat of nuclear war posed by NATO’s “nuclear doctrine.” Prof. Karl Hans Bläsius devoted himself to the topic of artificial intelligence and the risk of accidental nuclear war, which is possible at any time. Angelika Claußen, who is European President of the International Section of IPPNW/ Physicians for the Prevention of Nuclear War, presented the need for a European campaign – here is an excerpt from her speech:

“Yes, the peace movement is writing successes, we, the global civil society have pushed through the Nuclear Weapons Ban Treaty (TPNW) in alliance with the countries of the Global South and courageous outstanding women politicians from countries in Europe, from Austria, and from Ireland. We expected the resistance of the nuclear weapon states, because the TPNW is diametrically opposed to their interests! Now it is Europe’s turn! Nuclear sharing must be ended in Europe: in Germany, in Belgium, in the Netherlands and in Italy... The first step is to reject the nuclear dogma of NATO, the dogma of nuclear deterrence.

“And this is where a major current event comes into play: the defeat of the world power USA in Afghanistan. It is now crystal clear that military-based security policy is extremely destructive. The military and arms race, whether nuclear or non-nuclear, are totally inappropriate means to meet the challenges of humanity in times of climate crisis. The military itself is a climate killer. Instead, we need a civilian security and peace policy that implements important steps toward a social-ecological transformation with cooperative relations between our countries. Détente today, cooperative security policy, means drastic disarmament steps for climate justice. Nuclear-free Europe: that’s what we called our joint campaign to bring the peace movement into dialogue with politicians on how a roadmap to end nuclear sharing in Europe will look.... A world free of nuclear weapons, the containment of the climate crisis including climate justice, and our right to life and health — all these goals belong together! This is what we are working for together here in Büchel!”

Speakers from other European “nuclear sharing” countries included Guido van Leemput, a staff member on Foreign Policy and National Defense of the Fraction of the Socialist Party in the Netherlands, and is involved with Bike for Peace Holland. Ludo De Brabander is spokesman for the Belgian peace organization Vrede (“peace” in Flemish), which is organizing protests at the Belgian air base Kleine Brogel. Alfonso Navarra spoke as the Italian representative of the “Demanding Disarmists” and transmitted a joint proposal of Italian peace groups to the next COP26 UN Climate Change Conference in Glasgow demanding that the military’s carbon pollution be included in negotiations. Rudolf Gottfried spoke of the October 9th actions to be held against the NATO nuclear attack maneuver “Steadfast Noon” in Nörvenich.

The entire rally was recorded in a livestream (in German) and can be viewed on Youtube: www.youtube.com/watch?v=wxFABSdzBO0.

European Bike Tour (September 24-26):

Month of Action

Nuke Free Europe is a young European network that proclaimed September 2021 as a “Month of Action” for the abolition of nuclear sharing in NATO states. The human chain in Büchel was the first of many, and afterwards protests at nuclear weapons bases in the Netherlands (Volkel) and Belgium (Kleine Brogel) were connected with a bicycle tour that began in Aachen. On September 24, a delegation of ten set out on their bikes from Aachen’s “Fridays for Future” climate strike, where we distributed leaflets on climate, our network, nuclear weapons, and military CO2 emissions.

Arriving at Volkel (Netherlands) we were welcomed by about 70 people. A rally took place near the air base with members of the Dutch Left and Green parties and local anti-nuclear organizations. Afterwards, we cycled together around the base, where – like in Büchel – about 20 nuclear bombs are maintained and where Dutch pilots practice for their use. Afterward, we set off with our bicycles in the direction of Belgium.

The Belgian peace organization Vrede welcomed us at a campsite where we held networking discussions around a campfire until the early hours of the morning. On Sunday, September 26, we started early and joined 130 cyclists on the last stretch towards the Belgian air base Kleine Brogel, which like in Büchel, has about 20 US B61 nuclear bombs. With an international rally and a small human chain, we protested together and made many acquaintances.

Among the international participants was the American Susan Crane of Redwood City, California, who came via Amsterdam especially for her Büchel trial (September 29th in the Cochem district court). Before her trial, Susan participated in the protests in Volkel and Kleine Brogel!

Europe in danger

Our resistance is already generating a lot of pressure, because otherwise it is hard to explain that currently during the coalition negotiations on October 29, 2021, the head of the Munich Security Conference Wolfgang Ischinger is quoted in about 80 German newspapers warning that “Europe would be in danger without US nuclear weapons in Germany”. I quote from the press release of our campaign:

“A withdrawal of American nuclear weapons from Germany would ‘... pull the rug out from under Poland’s feet in terms of security policy’. Ischinger then raises the possibility that Poland might then ask that nuclear bombs be placed on its territory. The fact that Ischinger is considering this is playing with fire. As the longtime head of the so-called Security Conference in Munich, he must know that security requires trust. One basis for trust is that treaties are honored: ‘pacta sunt servanda’. NATO has made a contractual commitment not to station nuclear weapons in the new accession states, including Poland. This commitment was explicitly emphasized by the Scientific Services of the Bundestag (WD 2-3000-041/20 of April 29, 2020): ‘The NATO-Russia Founding Act (Founding Act on Mutual Relations, Cooperation and Security between the North Atlantic Treaty Organization and the Russian Federation) of May 27, 1997, rules out the stationing of nuclear weapons on the territory of new NATO members’.”

Ischinger knows, when Germany steps out, this will affect future decisions of the other European nuclear sharing countries: A possible domino effect!

In 2018, our campaign received the Oberhausener Church Prize, and in 2019 was awarded the Aachener Peace Prize for our anti-nuclear work in Büchel.

More information is at www.atomwaffenfrei.de; and at www.buechel-atombombenfrei.de

Marion Küpker, spokeswoman for the ‘Büchel is everywhere! nuclear weapons-free now’ campaign, peace officer on nuclear weapons at the Fellowship of Reconciliation Germany, and international coordinator in the DFG-VK against nuclear weapons — October 31, 2021

AUKUS – Catalyst for a Nuclear Arms Race

From END Info 27 - Download

By Steve Bell

The new pact between the Australian, British and US governments is the latest escalation in a new cold war on China, and the developing world. The “enhanced trilateral security partnership called AUKUS”(1) does not name China, but every single serious commentator has interpreted it as being aimed against the People’s Republic of China.

Coming exactly one month after the fall of Kabul, the announcement was a blessed relief for both Joe Biden and Boris Johnson. Biden reasserts US pre-eminence, weeks after it was humiliated by a foe without an air force. Johnson resumes the ‘Global Britain’ adventure, weeks after British power more closely resembled a globule.

For both of them, a policy shift has been made without reckoning with the past, or a messy national debate. The debacle of their governments, and NATO, in Afghanistan has been pushed off the news agenda.

Military aggression with no diplomatic frills

The text of the Joint Leaders Statement is notable not just for the absence of a specific reference to China. Equally notable is the complete absence of any diplomatic purpose in the pact.

There is some conventional diplomatic language – “our enduring ideals and shared commitment to the international rules-based order”: “our common traditions as maritime democracies”, and “our shared values”. But there is nothing which can be interpreted as proposals to actually lower tensions between the states in the Indo-Pacific region. That being the case, the diplomatic phrases simply function as cant concealing the threats to China and the developing nations in the region.

The most immediate, and long-term, significance of the pact is the decision of the US to release the technology required for the Australian Navy to acquire nuclear powered submarines. This is only the second time that the US has done so. The first being the agreement with Britain under the 1958 US-UK Mutual Defence Agreement”. All pact signatories stressed that this does not involve the aquisition of nuclear weapons by Australia.

Yet as the pact is escalating military tensions in the region, there are no guarantees on future developments. Certainly scepticism is in order when we read: “Our three nations are deeply committed to upholding our leadership on global non-proliferation” – this, half a year after Johnson committed Britain to a forty per cent increase in nuclear missiles.

Aside from Australia acquiring weapons grade uranium in its new submarines, the pact stresses growing “interoperability, commonality, and mutual benefit”. All of which strengthens the US without additional cost, taxpayers in Australia and Britain will be funding this. Most certainly the pact does nothing to strengthen the independent “power” of Australia or Britain. Former prime minister of Australia, Paul Keating, nailed this when he characterised the agreement as a “further dramatic loss of Australian sovereignty”.

Finally, the composition of the pact – an oligopoly of white majority, anglo-saxon, imperialist states – is in stark contrast to the majority composition of the peoples of the region.

International opposition to the pact

In the west, opposition to the pact has been presented as most centrally from inside the EU. Australia cancelled its submarine contract with the French firms, worth around $66billion. French Foreign Minister, Jean-Yves Le Drian, said: “This brutal, unilateral and unpredictable decision reminds me a lot of what Mr Trump used to do. I am bitter and angry. This isn’t done between allies”. The French government has withdrawn its ambassadors from the US and Australia. There was no point in withdrawing their ambassador to Britain, as Johnson’s government has no independent agency in the pact. Le Drian, on French television, compared Britain’s role to a “fifth wheel on a wagon”.

The discomfort of the French has been felt, if less strongly, within the EU. The complete absence of consultation with the EU about the timing of the US’s drawdown from Afghanistan remains a recent sore spot. Now, the signing of the pact represents another accomplished fact for the US allies in the EU. Josep Borrell, EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security, said that what was needed was “more cooperation, more coordination and less fragmentation” to achieve peace and stability in the Indo-Pacific Region. This was particularly heartfelt, as the EU’s painfully negotiated, new Indo-Pacific strategy was overshadowed by the pact’s announcement the day before the EU document’s publication.

It is unclear how this diplomatic spat will be resolved. Whether the French, and other governments, will seek to strengthen the EU’s “autonomy” is an open question. The EU has suffered one major blow, as Trump’s US succeeded in wrenching the UK out. But though weakened, the EU and the French government, will also be anxious to restore normal relations with Biden and the US.

But of far greater significance, and much less reported, than European opposition is the response inside the Indo Pacific. China, of course, understands the completely hostile character of the pact. Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson, Zhao Lijian, said that the three countries were “severely damaging regional peace and stability, intensifying an arms race, and damaging international nuclear non-proliferation efforts”.

This response was endorsed by other significant states. On 17th September, Indonesia’s foreign affairs spokesperson, Teuku Faizasyah said: “Indonesia is deeply concerned over the continuing arms race and power projection in the region”. He added: “Indonesia calls on Australia to maintain its commitment towards regional peace, stability and security in accordance with the Treaty of Amity and Cooperation”. The Treaty is the code of conduct between the Association of South-East Asian Nations (ASEAN).

Another ASEAN nation strongly opposed the pact. Malaysian Prime Minister, Ismail Sabri Yaakob, defined AUKUS as a “catalyst for a nuclear arms race in the Indo-Pacific region”. He added: “As a country within ASEAN, Malaysia holds the principle of maintaining ASEAN as a Zone of Peace, Freedom and Neutrality”.

Concern to keep the peace in the Pacific led the New Zealand government to oppose the pact. On 16th September, Prime Minister Jacinda Arden stated that Australia’s new nuclear powered submarines would not be allowed into New Zealand’s territorial waters under its 1984 nuclear free policy.

The pact signatories have considerable histories of intervening against national liberation movements in the region. Inevitably there will be concern about their agreement to increase their military profile. The new, nuclear element is a particularly sharp issue for the region. Between 1946 and 1958, the US tested 92 nuclear devices on Pacific islands. Between 1952 and 1958, Britain teasted 21 nuclear devices on Pacific atolls, and in Australian desert locations. It was the peoples of the region who suffered from the resulting fallout.

Building bases for war

Although not highlighted at the time, the pact’s announcement also involves an increase in base-building by the US in Australia. On September 16th, Australia’s Defense Minister, Peter Dutton, reported to a press conference on plans to establish new armed forces facilities with “… combined logistics, sustainment, and capability for maintenance to support enhanced activities, including … for our submarines and surface combatants” and “rotational deployments of all types of US military aircraft to Australia”. The US already has at least seven installations in Australia.(2)

Increasing base numbers cannot be defined as defence, this is increasing forward platforms for offensive action. These will be added to the upwards of 750 US bases worldwide, after the withdrawal from Afghanistan. 750 bases is nearly three times the combined number of embassies, consulates and missions of the US worldwide. Approximately 400 of the bases are situated in countries suitable for offensive action against China.

There has been no new announcement of additional bases for Britain in the region. Currently the UK has around 60 military personnel deployed at various locations in Australia.(3) This includes a drone testing site. Britain has other bases suitable for confronting China, including a naval logistics base in Singapore, a naval base in Brunei, three facilities in Nepal, as well as training facilities in Pakistan, and personnel at unspecified locations in New Zealand. Nor should it be overlooked that Britain has recently acquired naval base facilities in Bahrain and Oman which are linked to the use of the two new aircraft carriers. One of these has already been used in the provocative deployment of a carrier strike group into the seas around China. Again, the location of these bases defends neither the population, nor the territory of the UK, they are forward, aggressive placements. With 145 bases worldwide, that tops the combined number of 84 British embassies and 49 consulates worldwide.

In comparison, the “predatory”, “assertive”, and “rising” China has one overseas military base in Djibouti. In the same tiny country, there is the most extensive, permanent US base in the African continent, alongside the bases of five other countries. It is difficult to see how this deployment is a threat to the US or UK. But facts should not be allowed to interfere with the developing narrative for a new cold war.

Bipartisan politics in support of the new cold war

The House of Commons debate on September 16th demonstrated, once again, that Labour, under Keir Starmer, is in essential agreement with the Tory Party in promoting the cold war on China. A bouyant Boris Johnson explained that: “Australia has … taken the momentous decision to acquire a fleet of nuclear-powered submarines and it asked for our help in achieving this ambition. I am delighted to tell the House that we have agreed to this request…” In his enthusiasm he must have forgotten to explain that it will have been the US that decided on the release of the technology.

He gravely explained how we are joined to Australia by “blood and history” – while presumably the millions of Chinese who died as a result of British colonialism in their country had neither blood, nor history. Nor could he contain his glee that there will be “hundreds of highly skilled jobs across the UK”. Clearly nuclear proliferation is a price worth paying for “hundreds” of jobs.

Starmer’s response was in line with his general approach of supporting Tory foreign policy. Increasing military spending and increasing nuclear warheads had been endorsed when he welcomed the government’s strategic military review, earlier this year. However, he was aware that the international situation was not quite as bright and simple as Johnson suggested. He said: “The lesson of the past few weeks is that Britain must look after our most important relationships, or our influence and security quickly decline”. This was an odd thing to say – given that our “most important” ally had acted entirely without reference to Britain in those “few weeks”. But such painful truths are best suppressed.

Starmer did raise a very interesting question when he said: “…the UK must maintain a commercial relationship with China… So what plan does the Prime Minister have to ensure that this new arrangement increases rather than decreases our ability to influence China?” After all, nuclear escalation is not the best calling card to offer a trading partner. Johnson responded by squaring the circle, explaining that the pact: “is not intended to be adversarial towards any other power: it merely reflects… the close relationship that we have with the United States and Australia”. Immediately after, Tory MP Tobias Ellwood said: “We must work with and stand up to China. This is about a more coordinated, long-term strategy in challenging China’s increasing, hostile dominance in the South China Sea”. Strangely enough, Johnson didn’t bother to correct Ellwood.

Starmer’s parliamentary position was endorsed by Lisa Nandy in a Sky interview, that same day. Whilst she reiterated the general stance of supporting the Tory government position, Nandy did add to Starmer’s question about the tension between war-mongering and trading. She said: “We have to take a far more strategic approach to how we manage that relationship and that involves working with our allies, which is why we welcome today’s announcement and we’d like to see the government go further”.

The luxury, or consolation, of opposition is to criticise the government without explaining your alternative. Nothing in her interview suggested what Labour’s “more strategic approach” might entail. After all, the Shadow Front Bench has endorsed the idea of China as a “systemic competitor”. The Tories record levels of increased military spending and increasing nuke numbers is one possible strategic response to a competitor. Having endorsed this expenditure, and its international furtherance in AUKUS, what really can Labour suggest as a more strategic approach? Do not hold your breath in anticipation.

For the anti-war movement, and socialists inside Labour, AUKUS must be opposed. Locking Britain into decades of nuclear escalation in the Pacific is globally dangerous, hugely expensive and totally unnecessary.

Notes:

(1) Joint leaders statement on AUKUS, 15/9/21

(2) “Drawdown: Improving U.S. and Global Security Through Military Base Closures Abroad”, Quincy Institute 20/9/21

(3) “The UK military’s overseas base network involves 145 sites in 42 countries”, Declassified website, 24/11/20

First published at labouroutlook.org

AUKUS and other troubles

From END Info 27 - download

Norway’s decision to send observers to the TPNW Meeting of State Parties, scheduled for March 2022 in Vienna, should we warmly welcomed. Norway is the first NATO member state to ‘break ranks’ with that organisations’ determined effort to undermine the global nuclear ban. Norway’s decision is the product of a coalition agreement between the Labor Party and Center Party embodied in the ‘Hurdal platform’, named after the Norwegian municipality where it was drafted.

Prior to the elections, Labor had moved decisively to strengthen commitments to making progress on nuclear disarmament. Unlike many other political parties, Labor maintained pre-election commitments on this question after the polls closed.

NATOs reaction to this development, represented by comments from Jens Stoltenberg - himself a former Norwegian Prime Minister - are instructive:

"NATO's position on the Treaty of Prohibition is very clear; we do not believe in that treaty as a path to nuclear disarmament. And I expect everyone to take this into account when addressing nuclear weapons issues and consulting closely with other NATO allies."

Stoltenberg’s school-masterly scolding of the new Norwegian government has not gone down well. Two other former Norwegian Prime Ministers took Stoltenberg to task in the pages of the Verdens Gang newspaper, writing:

73 percent of Norwegians believe that nuclear weapons create more risk than security, according to a survey conducted by Respons Analyze for Norwegian People's Aid. This majority deserves a government that takes the nuclear threat seriously. The Hurdal platform gives us hopes that we now have this. For as the UN Secretary-General says: "We must reject" the toxic and erroneous logic "of nuclear deterrence”, because "humanity remains one misunderstanding, one mistake, one miscalculation, one push of a button away from being wiped out."

Rather than take such matters seriously, Stoltenberg, the organisation he represents and the dominant political forces within it – nuclear powers one and all – continue with their determined crusade re-arm, expand and increase global tensions.

That such efforts continue without pause following the shambolic evacuation of NATO forces from Afghanistan would be remarkable if not for the fact that NATO ultimately serves – as it has always served – the geopolitical and strategic interests of the United States.

One example of the dynamics of these interests is to be found in the recent announcement of the AUKUS agreement between Australia, the UK and United States. What else to make of this agreement other than as another artefact of the ongoing and accelerating ‘tilt to Asia’. Stoltenberg didn’t find the time to issue warnings to the UK and US about “consulting closely with NATO allies” when fellow-NATO member France lost out financially from the agreement.

What of the fact that all NATO members are also full participants in the Non-Proliferation Treaty? What of the serial breaches of nuclear-armed NATO members and the arms race they have sparked? No word from Stoltenberg.

What of the ‘carbon bootprint’ of NATO operations? When the world is focussed on COP26, Stoltenberg’s appearance in Glasgow came with no commitments on this question.

The new Norwegian government was right to follow the instructions of the electorate – and their own political good sense – in deciding to attend the Meeting of State Parties. Will more follow their lead? There is hope!

Europe and NATO Expansion

From END Info 26 DOWNLOAD

Frank Blackaby

download.jpg

Frank Blackaby was Director of the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute from 1981 to 1986. First published as a pamphlet of the same title by Spokesman for the European Labour Forum in July 1996. We republish here for historical context and as a contribution towards further analysis of NATO’s policy, dynamics and the dangers it poses.

* * * * *

Introduction

If you say ‘Europe’ to anyone in Britain these days, it triggers comments on beef, fish, the Conservative Party, and, just possibly, the Inter-Governmental Conference. These are ephemerae. The big issue is as it has always been – how do we make sure that we never again have a great war in Europe? We failed twice this century. It would be wicked to fail again. Could it happen? The way things are going, the answer is – Yes.

Five years ago, peace over the whole of Europe was there for the taking. Western Europe was already a ‘security enclave’, in this sense: that it was absurd to think that the three old contenders – France, Britain and Germany – would ever again resort to military force to settle disputes between them. Germany had been brought into the Western comity of states: it was no longer an expansionist power. Then from 1985 on, Gorbachev set about removing for good the idea of Soviet expansionism.

It is easy to forget the enormity, and the totality, of that change. Indeed it was not one change: it was about nine changes. The Berlin Wall came down. All Soviet troops left Eastern Germany, and all other Warsaw Pact states as well. The Warsaw Pact was dissolved. The USSR broke up, and two new states were created – Belarus and the Ukraine which stood between Russia and Poland. So Russian troops, withdrawn to their new border, were over 1,000 kilometres away from the new German border. The USSR accepted the reunification of Germany.

There was more. In the five years before its dissolution, the USSR assented to a whole series of Western arms control proposals. It accepted a total zero for all ground-launched ballistic and cruise missiles with ranges from 500km to 5,500km – a proposal the US had put forward in the certainty that the USSR would turn it down. The USSR signed a Treaty on Conventional Forces in Europe which meant far more dismantling and destruction of weapon systems on the Eastern than on the Western side. It agreed to a START Treaty reducing Soviet nuclear weapons much more than those of the US.

Finally, any idea of furthering the worldwide spread of Communism was abandoned. What else could the USSR (and later Russia) have done, to convince the world that it was not an aggressive expansionist power?

A chance

Here then was a chance. For the first time in recorded history there was a chance to create a Europe from the Atlantic to the Urals where the risk of inter-state (not intra-state) war could be reduced down towards zero. This had already happened in Western Europe. Within the region of the European Union security was no longer a military matter. In any dispute between EU members, their relative military capability was irrelevant. Even the fiercest British Eurosceptic, angry at the ban on British beef exports, does not suggest calling the chiefs of staff into Cabinet meetings. The idea of settling disputes within the EU by military means is off the map of political possibility.

This ‘security enclave’ could have been extended to Eastern Europe. Two things were needed. One was to bring Russia into the comity of nations as an equal partner as had already been done with the Second World War enemy, Germany. The other was to avoid at all costs the creation of a new dividing line in Europe. There should be no going back to the old pattern – an alliance of selected European states against the threat from a European enemy outside the group.

The opportunity was lost. It is not going to be easy to salvage things now.

NATO was clearly not the right body for the new Europe. The North Atlantic Treaty, the Washington Treaty, is a simple, monochrome Treaty. Security organisations fall into two classic categories. There are collective security treaties, which are concerned primarily with conflicts between their members and there are collective defence treaties, which are created to deal with an enemy or enemies outside the group. The Washington Treaty is a collective defence treaty, addressed to an outside threat. It is not - repeat not a collective security treaty. It has no provisions for dealing with conflicts between its own members. That is one reason why it is so short: it can be printed out on one sheet of A4 paper.

Further, NATO was a single-enemy treaty. It had one purpose and one purpose only – to deter the USSR from an attack on Western Europe. It was a military treaty, and nothing else. It had no concern with human rights – there was no question of suspending Greece or Turkey when they were under military dictatorships. It had nothing to do with economic issues. Its purpose was to confront an enemy, the Soviet Union, with military power.

How has it been possible to promote NATO as the dominant security organisation in Europe, when the Soviet Union was no longer the enemy? There has been no revision to the Washington Treaty of 1949. It is still for collective defence, and that presumes some enemy. These are some answers to that question.

The promotion of NATO

It soon became clear that, in spite of the loss of the enemy, NATO would remain the United States’ chosen instrument of influence in Europe. The US had no intention of allowing the Pan-European Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe (the CSCE, later the OSCE) to take its place. In NATO, the United States had an undisputed position of leadership. It dominated NATO’s decision-making process – for the threat, spoken or unspoken, of US withdrawal from Europe was always there. The CSCE was much too European for American tastes. The USA had (in its view) won the Cold War. Russia was in a chaotic state, so that there was no need to pay much attention to Russian views on any security issue. The general US attitude was: ‘We are the masters now’.

In the early period after the fall of the Berlin Wall, some of the Eastern European states, former members of the Warsaw Pact, initially favoured the idea of a pan-European security body. They changed their minds when they understood the US position. Their long period of subjection to Soviet hegemony had left them with one main security obsession: to stay out of any Russian sphere of influence. They wanted a guarantee from the United States that this would not be permitted. The only way they saw of obtaining that guarantee was by becoming members of NATO. For them, NATO was still an organisation for deterring Russia. As one Polish diplomat put it – though not on a diplomatic occasion: ‘We are not interested in the fun and games. [He was referring to Partnership for Peace manoeuvres, discussed below]. We just want to make sure that, if there is trouble with Russia, the US marines will be there’.

NATO moved in a somewhat crab-like way to its present position, of accepting the idea that states which were previously members of the Warsaw Pact should be enrolled as full members of NATO. The first move, in 1991, was to establish the North Atlantic Cooperation Council, open to all Central and East European states and later to all the successor states of the old USSR. Virtually all the eligible states joined. The Council’s function was to provide consultation on defence planning and other military matters. Whether in fact Tajikistan, Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan have benefited much from such consultations is perhaps doubtful.

The next step was to develop with some of these states Partnership for Peace (PfP) programmes. It is always as well to be wary when military organisations adopt the word ‘Peace’. The US Strategic Air Command had as its motto ‘Peace is our Profession’ at a time when it was sending B52s with nuclear bombs to loiter near the Soviet border. President Reagan decided to christen the MX Intercontinental Ballistic Missile the ‘Peacekeeper’ – though most of those writing about US nuclear weapons seem to have jibbed at using this designation.

‘Partnership for Peace’ programmes might suggest such items as educational programmes in schools designed to encourage children not to hate other nationalities, or the financing of films which show the appalling consequences of modern war. In fact the NATO Partnership for Peace programmes are concerned exclusively with the military: peace was a military matter, to be obtained by military means. So PfP programmes involve such items as joint military exercises, force planning and the development of interoperability. Russia accepted the idea of PfP programmes because it assumed that they were a relatively innocuous substitute for full NATO membership.

Then in January 1994 NATO, at US instigation, decided in principle to admit former Warsaw Pact states as full members of NATO. This epoch-making decision was taken with little public debate in Europe Europeans were preoccupied with Maastricht and all that. So PfP programmes, instead of being substitutes for NATO membership, were billed as part of the necessary preparations for full membership. The promise of full NATO membership has perhaps been made most explicitly to Poland. In July 1994 President Clinton, no doubt with Polish-American votes in mind, stated before the Polish Parliament: ‘Bringing new members into NATO, as I have said many times, is no longer a question of whether, but when and how’.

NATO eventually published a study on enlargement in September 1995. It conveys the message that this enlargement will improve security and stability for all states: the phrase ‘security and stability’, sometimes varied to read ‘stability and security’, appears thirty times in the first 11 pages of the paper. The early part of the paper accepts that things have changed, and that there is virtually no risk of ‘a re-emergent large-scale military threat’. It then refers to ‘risks to European security which are multi-faceted and multi-directional’. The facets or directions are not specified.

However, the later sections which deal with the modalities of expansion imply that nothing has changed. The conditions of membership are the same. There should be no change in the Treaty – it stays a collective defence Treaty. It is strongly suggested that it would be a good idea for new members to accept the stationing of other allied forces on their territory: ‘. . . the stationing of allied forces offers specific military advantages in relation to collective defence’. However, this should be ‘neither a condition of membership nor foreclosed as an option’.

On nuclear weapons, ‘there is no a priori requirement for the stationing of nuclear weapons on the territory of new members’: however, this also is not foreclosed. New members must accept NATO’s nuclear weapon doctrine, which still includes possible first use. President Havel of the Czech Republic recently changed the view he previously held, and now allows for the possibility of nuclear weapons on Czech soil. The document states: ‘New members should concentrate, in the first instance, on interoperability’. That means that new weapon systems should be bought from manufacturers in NATO countries, not any longer from Russia.

Consequences

This decision – the Eastwards expansion of NATO – seems to have been taken without asking what would happen next. Here three questions are asked. What would happen to relations between Russia and the West? What about the new dividing line, between those states which are in NATO and those which are not? If Poland, Hungary, and the Czech Republic join NATO, will they be more secure?

The NATO document on enlargement has a section on relations with Russia. It leaves a vague impression of Russian cooperation, although it does concede that ‘Russia has raised concerns with respect to the enlargement process of the Alliance’. This is a massive understatement. The document offers this anodyne reply to those concerns: ‘. . . The Alliance has made it clear that the enlargement process ... will threaten no-one and contribute to a developing broad European architecture based on true cooperation throughout the whole of Europe, enhancing security and stability for all’.

How does the idea of NATO extension play in Petrozavodsk? Not well. In Russia, unlike Western Europe, the expansion of NATO has been extensively discussed. There is a consensus: it is negative. In 1993 Yevgeniy Primakov, now Foreign Minister, said that if ‘the biggest military grouping in the world with colossal offensive potential moved closer to Russia’s borders, then this would call for ‘a substantial reassessment of the Russian defence concept and a redeployment of armed forces, a change in operative plans’. More recently we have had the speech of the Russian Deputy Defence Minister, Andrei Kokoshin, who in the 1988-92 period had been one of the more prominent advocates of Soviet accommodation with the West. In February this year he reminded a Munich audience that the 1990 Treaty on the Final Settlement with Respect to Germany prohibited the stationing of foreign troops in Germany’s eastern Lander: the point of the prohibition had been precisely to prevent any Eastward move for NATO. Now NATO was proposing an extension which leap-frogged east Germany and which could bring possibly nuclear weapons and very probably foreign troops even further to the East. Kokoshin said that it would usher in a new era of ‘dangerous confrontation’.

In Russia the condemnation of the NATO decision seems universal – in articles, think-tank reports, reactions of political parties and collective statements from the Russian equivalent of the ‘great and good’. Opinions differ about what Russia should do if it happens. These are three of the more moderate proposals (the extremists want a military reoccupation of the Baltic republics):

(a) Russia should move to build up a military-political alliance to counter NATO expansion. Belarus would certainly join, and Russia would put great pressure on Ukraine to join as well. President Kuchma of Ukraine has already spoken in Moscow, opposing NATO expansion. So a new, hostile border would be created, between Poland and the states to the East.

(b) Russia should then reintroduce ground-based tactical nuclear weapons to protect the border. Since NATO would then have a formidable superiority in conventional forces, Russia would have to rely much more on nuclear warheads. The decision to withdraw ground-based tactical nuclear weapons was a kind of gentlemen’s agreement between Bush, Gorbachev and later Yeltsin. There is no Treaty to prevent their reintroduction. Agreement would be sought to put them on the Belarus-Polish border.

(c) Russia should not ratify either the START II Treaty or the Open Skies Treaty until the idea of an Eastward expansion of NATO is jettisoned.

For the moment Western politicians have put the idea of NATO expansion on the back burner. They hope, by their temporary silence, to be of some help to President Yeltsin’s campaign. No doubt President Zyuganov would react more fiercely if the expansion does happen. However, in Russia the hostility to the idea is so widespread that any President would be bound to take some action of some kind - military as well as political – if the expansion goes ahead.

Which states?

The leading candidates for joining NATO are Poland, Hungary and the Czech Republic; Slovakia is more doubtful. The states at the bottom of the list are the Baltic Republics. This is in some ways a rather odd ranking. In spite of disclaimers, the applicant states are interested in NATO membership for one reason and one reason only - as protection against a resurgent Russia. The Baltic states could claim to be in the greatest need, because of their problems with substantial Russian minorities. However, NATO Governments recognise that if these states joined NATO all hell would break loose in Russia: so the Baltic states are at the end of the queue.

So what would happen if Poland, Hungary, and the Czech Republic became full members of NATO? There would be a clear new dividing line in Europe. Further, there would be a de facto declaration of spheres of influence. The Western powers would be saying to Russia, in effect: ‘We will take those three states into the Western sphere of influence. You can have the rest’. There is no way in which this decision could fail to make a new dividing line in Europe – and a hostile one at that. As a consequence Russia might well put pressure on the Baltic states, on Belarus and on the Ukraine to accept the stationing of Russian forces on their territory.

If Poland, Hungary and the Czech Republic joined NATO, would they in fact be more secure? One argument used a good deal is that these three states are in a ‘security vacuum’. This metaphor was extensively used in the debates on NATO expansion in the US Congress. Representative Christopher Smith, for example, described central Europe as a ‘no-man’s land ... between Germany and Russia’. He cited US political, economic, and security interests on the continent, and argued that NATO could fill a vacuum that would sustain progress made towards democracy and free-market economies in the region.

The vacuum metaphor is not helpful. Vacuums have to be filled by something. The implication is clear: if NATO doesn’t move in, Russia will. Why would Russia ‘move in’, whatever that might mean? It has no common border with the three states any longer. Which would be more profitable for Russia - good relations with these three states, or bad relations? Again, the parallel with Western Europe is useful. Belgium and the Netherlands have common borders with militarily powerful states. They are in a ‘security vacuum’: NATO does not fill it, since it has no provision for dealing with disputes between Treaty members. For Belgium and the Netherlands the concept of a security vacuum is meaningless: their relations with France and Germany are such that the overwhelming military power of those two states is not relevant.

The sensible course for the three applicant states is to work on developing good relations with Russia, which should not be difficult. If they join NATO, that will simply help to bring about the very thing they fear – a Russia which stops the decline in military spending, starts to build up more powerful military forces, and moves back to military confrontation with the West.

The applicant states should note that the ‘NATO guarantee’ in Article V of the Washington Treaty is not unequivocal. It does begin by saying that ‘an armed attack against one or more [allies] shall be considered an attack against them all’. However, it then goes on to say that each party to the Treaty will assist the ally under attack with ‘such action as it deems necessary, including the use of armed force.’ There is no unequivocal military commitment. In the US Congressional debate opponents of NATO expansion said that, due to US conventional force reductions in Europe, such expansion would ‘create a dangerous gulf between our commitments in Europe and the resources required to meet them’. Representative Hamilton said that ‘these conventional force reductions would leave too great a reliance on US strategic nuclear forces to meet the US commitment’. Would the US really threaten a nuclear war in defence of Poland?

However, in spite of this questioning, NATO’s military establishment in Brussels has probably already started military contingency planning for three new entrants. It is hard to think of any realistic contingencies – a Russian incursion into Poland through Belarus? – but no doubt military imagination will think of something. There has already been discussion about Poland’s flat terrain: does it give more advantage to the invader or the defender? It clearly suggests the use of heavy armour, and that in turn suggests prepositioning. The next stage would be military exercises, which would provoke counter-exercises on the other side. No doubt some of those on the military side in NATO would find it in some ways comforting to be back to business as usual.

For Poland, Hungary and the Czech Republic, the cost of joining NATO, and obtaining such guarantees as Article V provides, is likely to be a much more hostile border to the East. This is a doubtful bargain.

How to get out of this mess

It will not be easy to find a way out of this foolish and unnecessary confrontation with Russia, because neither side will want to lose face. The Americans – fully conscious of their position as the one remaining superpower – have promised NATO membership particularly to Poland. They seem determined to take no notice of anything the Russians say. The Russians, increasingly angry at being treated as some kind of basket case whose views can be totally ignored, would have to do something if this Eastward expansion went ahead. The NATO decision in principle, and the US refusal to accept any modifications which might make the decision more palatable, has already served to increase Russian hostility to the West.

Once it is accepted that NATO’s present policy will build up great trouble for the future, it should be possible to find a proposal less provocative to the Russians. For example, NATO and Russia could jointly agree to guarantee existing borders in Central and Eastern Europe. There is the Ukrainian proposal, for a nuclear-weapon-free zone from Sweden in the North to Bulgaria in the South, taking in all the Central and East European states. The range of non-provocative possibilities is wide. The dominant requirements for European security remain - that Russia should be within the structure and not outside it, and that there should be no new dividing line in Europe.

According to Article 10 of the Washington Treaty, any invitation to a new state to join NATO has to have the unanimous agreement of all the existing members. In the debates in the US Congress, the representatives seem not to have noticed this particular clause. They clearly regarded NATO expansion as a matter for the United States alone to decide. Perhaps one or other of the European members of NATO might be prepared to incur US displeasure, and indicate that it might be better to wait for a more comprehensive European security agreement.

Envoi

It is silly to keep repeating that NATO’s Eastwards expansion will not create a new dividing line in Europe. Of course it will. It is silly to revert to the old ‘fallacy of the last move’ that once NATO moves Eastwards, it is the end of the game. It is not. The Russian Government – any Russian Government – will react, militarily as well as politically. Those who draft NATO documents seem to believe that, if they intone the mantra ‘security and stability’ thirty times, all problems will disappear. They will not. The course is being set for Europe to drift gradually downwards towards Cold War II – ‘that stale imposture played on us once again’.

Nuclear Disarmament is a precondition for real security in Europe

From END Info 26 DOWNLOAD

Ludo De Brabander – Büchel 07/07/2021

eurorubix.jpg

We can look with optimism or pessimism to the future.

On the negative side: it appears that we are living in a more dangerous decade compared to even the difficult episodes of the cold war. In the last two consecutive years, the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists set the hands of the ‘Doomsday Clock’ – measuring the likelihood of man-made global catastrophe – at one hundred seconds to midnight – closer than it has ever been before, due to the imminent threats of nuclear war and climate disaster. Arms control treaties are no longer upheld, and governments have started updating and expanding nuclear arsenals.

But there are also hopeful developments. On 22 January 2021, the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW) entered into force. Meanwhile 54 states ratified the Ban Treaty. A milestone in history. Four years ago (the 7th of July 2017), after several years of negotiations, 122 countries voted in favour of the new Ban Treaty, with one against (Netherlands), and 1 official abstention (Singapore).

Unfortunately, 69 nations did not vote at all. They didn’t even take part in the negotiations. Among them the nuclear weapon states and all NATO members except the Netherlands.

NATO: nuclear alliance

NATO and governments of member states claim that the TPNW is incompatible with the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) and even undermines it. It is important to recall that a key motivation of the states that negotiated the TPNW was to take forward the implementation of the nuclear disarmament obligations of article VI of the NPT. This intention is also clearly stated in the preamble of the TPNW. Article VI of the NPT legally obliges all states parties to pursue “negotiations” and “effective measures” “on a treaty on general and complete disarmament under strict and effective international control”. That is exactly what the TPNW does. UN secretary-general, António Guterres, flatly rejected in 2018 in Geneva claims that the TPNW undermines the NPT declaring that the two treaties are “fully compatible” and complementary. The research services division of the German federal parliament, wrote in a detailed paper in January 2021: “The TPNW does not undermine the NPT; it is part of a common nuclear disarmament architecture.”

Nevertheless, despite the obligations under article VI of the NPT, most NATO member states as well as all nuclear states, have been boycotting the negotiations. Worse, NATO started a disinformation campaign with the false claim that the Ban Treaty undermines the nuclear disarmament regime. The real reason is that NATO sees the treaty as a threat to the organization's political unity over its nuclear strategy. According to NATO: “Nuclear weapons are a core component of NATO's overall capabilities for deterrence and defence, alongside conventional and missile defence forces. NATO is committed to arms control, disarmament and non- proliferation, but as long as nuclear weapons exist, it will remain a nuclear alliance.”

However, NATO defined itself only recently as a nuclear alliance. In NATO's earliest years, nuclear weapons were in fact not even mentioned in the alliance's strategic concepts. Nuclear arms were considered as a responsibility of NATO's nuclear states. Only in the last decade did NATO accept a strategic concept in which it considered itself a ‘nuclear alliance’.

The collectivization of nuclear responsibility

From the 1960s, the US began to deploy nuclear weapons in other NATO member states, giving them a role in the planning and preparation of nuclear war. In the years that followed, all countries except France became involved in the nuclear deterrent policy, which was increasingly defined as a form of alliance solidarity. The reason?

International support among the population for nuclear disarmament grew. In the 80’s many hundreds of thousands demonstrated in European and US cities opposing new deployments of nuclear arms. The strengthening of humanitarian and anti-nuclear norms during and after the Cold War played a key role in pushing NATO to adapt.

This led to the collectivization of political responsibility for nuclear weapons.

Why? First, the nuclearization of NATO as an organizational identity allowed pro- nuclear actors to justify costly nuclear modernization programs and nuclear deployments as contributions to alliance "solidarity" and "cohesion". Second, this nuclearization of NATO undercut the potential for intra-alliance resistance to nuclear arms. Calls for nuclear disarmament could thus be seen as anti-NATO.

Nuclear sharing became a core component of NATO’s strategy. Of the three nuclear powers in NATO (France, the United Kingdom and the United States), only the United States has nuclear arms in other member states: Belgium, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands and Turkey. Once there were also US nuclear arms in Canada (1950-1984), Greece (until 2001) and the UK (until 1992). This means, by the way, that it was possible to send nuclear weapons back to the United States without it being considered an act against ‘NATO obligations’.

Currently, the US has about 150 tactical B61 gravity bombs deployed in Europe. They have to be mounted into (not in Turkey) dual capable aircraft (DCA) in war time. This can be considered as a transfer of control by non-nuclear states of nuclear arms which would be in breach with the non-proliferation treaty (NPT) of 1970. The NPT prohibits the direct or indirect transfer or control of nuclear weapons to non-nuclear states. But according to the US the NPT is not valid anymore in war time (argument: the purpose of the NPT to avoid war failed).

These bombs will soon be replaced by new B61-12 bombs. They are equipped with an electronic tail kit that can guide the bomb to its target. They have also lower yield options. The mixture of both, precision and lower yield options could be seen by war planners as more ‘useable’ allowing some targets that previously would not have been attacked because of too much collateral damage to be attacked anyway. This is a very dangerous development. The new B61-12 will increase the danger of a war with nuclear weapons eroding the concept of ‘deterrence’.

European population opposes nuclear weapons

According to recent surveys in several European countries, a majority of the population in Europe is in favour of a ban on nuclear weapons. This is what 77% of those surveyed want in Belgium, 89% in Spain, 87% in Italy, 78% in the Netherlands and Denmark. The challenge for the peace movement is to translate that support from the population into political pressure and to get nuclear weapons back high on the political agenda. For several months, representatives of the peace movement have been preparing a call to hold a month of actions against nuclear weapons in September 2021. We must not miss that opportunity because in a few years' time the new B61-12 bombs will be deployed in Europe. We are also witnessing an increase in investments by nuclear weapon states for the maintainence and renewal of nuclear arsenals in nuclear weapon states. According to an ICAN report the nine nuclear weapon states invested 72.6 billion dollars in 2020, an increase of 1.4 billion compared to 2019. The billions thrown away on nuclear weapons could instead be funding health care, climate measures or for the promotion of social justice.

The world is at a crossroads and Europe has to make a strategic choice: remain part of the arms race or demonstrate global leadership by promoting a peaceful approach towards common global security.

I invite all of you to participate actively in the new "Nuke Free Europe" network against NATO's nuclear sharing policy and for the removal of all nuclear weapons in Europe. During the month of September, in Belgium, Germany, the Netherlands, Italy and the UK there will be actions near military bases with US nuclear weapons. Our first goal is to get nuclear arms back on the political agenda and to raise awareness among other movements (trade unions, the climate movement, women and youth movement) about the planetary threat of nuclear weapons and the need to act.

We need to discuss and find ways to increase pressure on governments of the nuclear sharing countries to embrace the vision of nuclear disarmament as a preventative tool for shaping Europe’s security environment. A first condition is to end nuclear ambiguity which means that the governments of nuclear sharing states acknowledge that nuclear weapons are deployed on its territories. We need a free and open democratic discussion so that the presence of nuclear weapons in the sharing countries can be politically and legally contested. As a peace movement we should join forces with social movements in Europe in making nuclear disarmament a political priority. We must believe that the return of the anti- nuclear mass movement of the eighties is not impossible. Secondly, we need a clear political commitment and time schedule for European nuclear disarmament, starting with negotiations between the US/NATO and Russia to dismantle US nuclear bombs followed by agreements on nuclear disarmament in France, UK and at least the European part of Russia. Once nuclear disarmament is achieved Europe can legally become a nuclear weapon free zone. At the same time the door is open for European countries to fulfil their obligations under the NPT and to sign and ratify the TPNW.

To recall the iconic slogan of Greenpeace: “No time to waste!”

Ludo De Brabander is a Belgian writer and spokesman for the Belgian peace organisation Vrede vzw. https://vrede.be/en

NATO, nuclear weapons and Europe

From END Info 26 DOWNLOAD

Joachim Wernicke

imagepeace.jpg

Evaluation of the communiqué on the NATO summit on 14 June 2021

It was a major endeavor to evaluate the 31-page NATO communiqué of June 14, 2021 (covering 79 topics, with much self-praise and repetition), in search of facts about the possible stationing of new US intermediate-range missiles in Europe. Following US President Trump’s termination of the 1987 INF Treaty in 2019, new such missiles – Long-Range Hypersonic Weapons (LRHW) for the US Army and Conventional Prompt Strike (CPS) for the US Navy – were tested and ordered, for delivery from 2024.

What follows are selected and annotated citations from the communiqué (topic numbers in brackets), in their own translation, as the original NATO text is published in English, French, Russian and Ukrainian, but not in German:

(3) “Russia’s aggressive actions pose a threat to Euro-Atlantic security.” So NATO officially states Russia is a military adversary.

(9) “While NATO adheres to international agreements, Russia continues to break the values, principles, trust and agreements that underlie the NATO-Russia relationship.” No indication of which agreements have been broken from NATO’s point of view. And the claim conceals the Western breaches of international agreements, for example: promises to the Soviet head of state Gorbachev in 1990 and the breaking of these promises by NATO’s eastward expansion since 1997; permanent stationing of NATO units in countries of the former Warsaw Pact, thereby breaking the NATO-Russia Basic Act.

(11) “(...) the creation of modern dual-capable [i.e. conventional and nuclear] missiles in Kaliningrad (...), which increasingly threaten the security of the Euro-Atlantic area.” NATO does not specify how, in its view, these missiles which have been stationed in the Russian enclave of Kaliningrad (formerly German North-East Prussia) since US President Trump’s termination of the INF Treaty in 2019 “increasingly threatens the security of the Euro-Atlantic area”. What is the difference between whether the missiles are stationed in Kaliningrad, in the Russian heartland or on Russian naval ships? Unfortunately, NATO is silent about the presumably important reason that Russia stations missiles in vulnerable circumstances in the small Kaliningrad area which is only the size of Thuringia and in the crosshairs of NATO guns from Poland, Lithuania and the Baltic Sea. And NATO fails to mention that it was US President Trump’s termination of the INF Treaty that allowed Russia to produce and deploy the intermediate-range missiles necessary to shell the US command structure in West Germany from Kaliningrad. Thus, this threat was caused by the NATO chief himself. The communiqué does not ask why this happened.

(22) “NATO is advancing a new military strategy through the implementation of two significant military concepts that will further strengthen our ability to deter and defend against any potential adversary and to maintain and develop our military lead in the future.” Thus, NATO confirms its superiority over the Russian armed forces, which is also known and documented by a comparison of the military budgets (the USA spends more than ten times that of Russia).

“The concept of warfare envisages a long-term vision for the maintenance and further development of NATO’s decisive military lead.” NATO confirms that it is preparing for warfare. But it fails to specify where the battlefield would be.

There is a general consensus that any warfare in Europe is incompatible with the protection of civilians in European countries, including Russia. That is why warfare in Europe inevitably means genocide. Successful military defence is no longer possible in Europe. On the other hand, non-violent civil defense is possible. Political problems in Europe can no longer be solved by military force. The main task of any European government is to prevent any warring party from bringing the effects of weapons of war to its territory. The reasons for this are Europe’s centralized infrastructure, the extreme dependence on electrical power and the lack of shelters for the civilian population.

(25) “We will not be constrained by any possible adversary regarding the movement of Alliance troops on land, in the air or at sea and within any part of the Alliance territory.” Thus, NATO claims the right to deploy new US intermediate-range missiles near Russia’s borders, despite the violation of the NATO-Russia Basic Act, and on Europe’s inland seas. NATO fails to mention that the presence and movement of foreign NATO troops on the soil of NATO members requires the prior permission of these members.

(26) “We reaffirm our commitment to respond in an appropriate, balanced, coordinated and timely manner to Russia’s growing and evolving range of conventional and nuclear-equipped missiles, which is increasing in scale and complexity, and which poses significant risks to security and stability in the Euro-Atlantic area from all strategic directions (...) We have no intention of stationing land-based nuclear missiles in Europe.” Thus, the new US intermediate-range missiles are claimed as a “response” to Russian missiles (following the example of NATO’s argument for the stationing of US intermediate-range missiles in Europe in the 1980s). And of the Russian missiles, it is claimed that they are “conventional and nuclear-deployable”. However, NATO fails to add that the new US LRHW and CPS intermediate-range missiles have the same technical feature of dual capability.

NATO avoids talking more precisely about its intentions with regard to new US medium-range missiles. Land-based conventionally equipped missiles and sea-based nuclear and conventionally equipped missiles are expressly not excluded. The U.S. government claims that the new LRHW and CPS missiles will only carry conventional warheads — the “C” stands for “conventional”. There are reasons to doubt the truth of this claim. Replacing conventional warheads with nuclear warheads is technically easy, and the lower weights of recent nuclear warheads gives the missile greater range.

(31) “In cases of hybrid warfare, the [NATO] Council could decide to invoke Article 5 of the Washington Treaty, as in the case of an armed attack.” The success of “hybrid warfare” against a state presupposes that it has delivered its critical infrastructure to insecure data networks – a self-inflicted vulnerability that can be easily avoided by appropriate technical protection measures and by humans instead of remote-controlled robots at critical control points. It is therefore doubtful that “hybrid warfare” or a “cyber attack” can be considered a military attack under Article 5 of the Charter of the United Nations – or whether it is merely a euphemism for and irresponsible dereliction of duty to exercise caution in data security. If I leave my front door open and then complain about a stolen item, who is to blame? The thieves or me? In World War II, no one could shut down a power plant or waterworks via a telephone line or a radio link.

NATO gives the impression here that the proclamation of Article 5 of the NATO Treaty is a strong measure of the NATO Council, which inevitably leads to military action against an adversary. However, this is not the case. NATO is ‘sovereignty-friendly’. Each member state decides individually how to proceed in the event of a NATO alliance case, ranging from a diplomatic touch of compassion to military participation. There is no obligation of any kind for the individual member state to participate in warfare that NATO intends or begins.

The only exception is those NATO member states that allow foreign troops on their soil. The sovereignty of these states is undermined because, under international law, foreign troops are allowed to stage military actions in alleged “self-defense”, at their own discretion, with weapons of their own choice, regardless of the decisions or wishes of the host country. This problem affects Germany and Great Britain, for example. On the other hand, France, Denmark, the Czech Republic and other NATO members act differently: no deployment of US troops.

(34) “We continue to improve our increased forward presence in Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and Poland by adapting to plans and by ensuring the ability of the four combat-ready battle groups to operate in conjunction with the national homeland defense forces.” Thus, NATO acknowledges that there is a permanent ‘reinforced forward estate’ in the territory of the former Warsaw Pact, consequently in violation of the NATO-Russia Founding Act.

(40) “The Alliance’s strategic forces, especially those of the United States, are the highest guarantee of allies’ security. The independent strategic nuclear forces of the United Kingdom and France have their own role and contribute significantly to the overall security of the Alliance. The separate decision-making centers of these allies contribute to deterrence by complicating the calculations of possible adversaries. NATO’s nuclear deterrence set-up is also based on United States nuclear weapons deployed forward in Europe and infrastructure provided by the allies concerned.” This fundamentally correct description results from the fact that NATO is legally a foreign legion of the US president. The Commander-in-Chief of U.S. Forces in Europe also serves as NATO Commander-in-Chief. The US nuclear weapons stationed forward in Europe allow the US president to cause crisis in Europe while keeping his the ‘homeland’ safe.

The French nuclear forces are outside this purely US national chain of command of NATO. Britain’s nuclear weapons use Trident II launchers leased from the US, so they must realistically be seen as part of the US national chain of command, at least as long as it is only a matter of blocking British actions that are not acceptable to the US government.

(44) “We have told Russia many times that the BMD system [ballistic missile defense] cannot work against Russia’s strategic nuclear deterrent [intercontinental ballistic missiles] and that there is no intention to redevelop this system in the future to give it the capability.” This claim is obviously false, because the GMD/GBI heavy defense system against intercontinental ballistic missiles is in use in California and Alaska.

(46) “NATO will continue to respond in an appropriate and responsible manner to the material risks posed by the Russian 9M729 missile to the security of the Alliance and by other short- and medium-range missiles (...) Russia’s proposal for a moratorium on the stationing of mid-lying missiles in Europe does not fit in with Russia’s unilateral and continued deployment of such systems on the continent and would not prevent Russia from deploying such missiles outside its European territory; this proposal is therefore not credible and unacceptable.” What kind of “essential risk” do Russian cruise missiles 9M729 (SSC-8) pose compared to Russian sea-based cruise missiles 3M14 (SS-N-30)? What other Russian short- and medium-range missiles pose such a “significant risk”?

Russia’s rejection of US claims of violation of the INF Treaty by SSC-8 has never been independently investigated. The SSC-8 thus serves as a pretext for stationing new US missiles in Europe, as the Soviet SS-20 missiles did in the 1980s.

This paragraph reveals the structure of NATO’s public relations work for the stationing of new US medium-range LRHW and CPS missiles in Europe: unlike in the 1980s, there will be no negotiations on a new INF Treaty, claiming that the Russian proposal was “not credible and unacceptable”. Due to the prevailing media coverage of corona and climate change, the European public has not yet noticed the situation of the new US missile stationing and its consequences.

(47) “Allies remain strongly committed to the full fulfillment of the NPT [Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty of 1968] and all its aspects, as an irreplaceable platform, and to strengthening the NPT through its mutually reinforcing three pillars (...) NATO’s nuclear arrangements have always been fully in line with the NPT, which is the only credible path to nuclear disarmament.” This NATO claim is obviously false: for more than 50 years, the three nuclear-weapon states in NATO have been permanently violating Article VI of the NPT, because during this time they have never sought nuclear disarmament “in good faith”, but have continuously participated in an international nuclear arms race.

“We reiterate our opposition to the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW), which does not fit with the Alliance’s nuclear deterrence strategy, is incompatible with the existing non-proliferation and disarmament architecture, risks undermining the NPT and does not take into account the current security environment. The TPNW does not change the legal obligations of our countries regarding nuclear weapons. We do not accept any argument that the TPNW in any way reflects or contributes to the development of customary international law.” NATO’s business model is based on nuclear weapons. That is why NATO rejects the TPNW, against the majority will of the peoples of NATO member states. But NATO’s claim that the TPNW “does not get along with the existing architecture for non-proliferation and disarmament” and “undermines the NPT” is false. The TPNW is based on the NPT and essentially corrects its fatal shortcoming, namely not to give a date for nuclear disarmament. Since 1968, the five nuclear-weapon states in the NPT have been taking advantage of this deficiency by mutual agreement, with the USA and Russia endangering the existence of civilization through their excessive nuclear armament. That is why signing the TPNW is the most important task of all governments today, even with priority over domestic tasks such as corona pandemic, climate protection, education, social services, etc.

All NATO member states except the US and Turkey are members of the International Criminal Court (ICC), which has been prosecuting and convicting war criminals since 2002. The legal standard for war crimes is the ICC’s interpretation of the international humanitarian law of war. The state of customary international law on nuclear weapons was established by the International Court of Justice in 1986, at the request of the UN General Assembly. The TPNW continues to strengthen this status, which also becomes important for states that are not participants in the TPNW.

As Richard Falk points out in The Spokesman 147 (Bertrand Russell Peace Foundation, 2021), UN General Assembly Resolution 1653 (XVI) of 1961 also has significance; it declared the threat of and use of nuclear weapons to be unconditionally illegal under the UN Charter. In addition, Falk points to the taboo on the use of nuclear weapons, which has been observed internationally since 1945, and to the NPT itself. Both documents have weight in delegitimizing and stigmatizing nuclear weapons, with 122 of the 193 UN members (63 percent) voting for the TPNW in 2017. Regardless of NATO positions, compliance with international humanitarian law is a duty of every single citizen of the European NATO states. After committing a war crime, he or she stands alone before the ICC – neither their government nor NATO are able to protect him or her against prosecution, conviction and punishment.

Conclusion

Russia is now in a much worse military situation than the Soviet Union was in 1984. At that time, there was a security strip about 1000 km wide as a separation from NATO territory. The Pershing II missiles in West Germany, with their accuracy of meters and flight time of about ten minutes, were seen in Moscow as presenting an acute danger of decapitation strike against the underground bunkered Soviet command structure. The Soviet missiles of that time did not yet have the accuracy necessary to reliably destroy deep underground bunker targets. Therefore, in a situation of acute military tension in Europe in the 1980s, the Soviet military would have led a massive area-wide first strike as far as foreseeable, primarily the mass of the European-based US military, concentrated in West Germany, with destruction of the entire country as collateral damage, with an atmospheric total explosive force of a few tens of megatons, complete loss of the German population, moderate damage caused by radioactive fallout in neighboring states (mainly in eastern states due to the main wind direction) and a large area in Central Europe uninhabitable for at least future centuries.

The US forces in West Germany would have been destroyed in this proxy war. But by mutual agreement, both sides would have strictly avoided nuclear hits on the core countries of the USA and the Soviet Union. Both sides (Reagan/Gorbachev) recognized the remaining risks for their countries and defused the nuclear duel in Europe by concluding the INF Treaty with each other in 1987.

Today, the situation is fundamentally different. As a part of NATO’s eastward expansion, the new US medium-range missiles will be stationed directly near the Russian land border and in the Baltic Sea and the Black Sea. As a result of their longer range (around 2700 km), these missiles will be LRHW and CPS – faster than the old Pershing II, which will shorten flight times. This makes a nuclear decapitation strike on the command bunkers in Moscow possible within about five minutes. Given this stronger US position, there will be no new INF Treaty, not even negotiations with Russia, as NATO has made explicitly clear.

On the other hand, instead of a few tens of megatons of nuclear explosive power on West Germany in the past, Russia has gained a unique new and advantageous situation, thanks to the termination of the INF Treaty by US President Trump. With this termination, Russia was again given the freedom to produce and station land-based medium-range missiles. Due to technical progress in accuracy, a first strike with “only” a small number of nuclear hits of so-called “small” explosive force (comparable to Hiroshima/Nagasaki) would be sufficient to decapitate the bunkered US command system in Europe, which is located (also for the new missiles) in West Germany (at least with targets in Stuttgart, Ramstein, Wiesbaden and Spangdahlem). The enclave of Kaliningrad (formerly Königsberg, East Prussia) is in a sufficiently close firing position for medium-range ballistic missiles, about 1000 km or seven minutes flight time away from the US bunkers in Germany. The required total nuclear explosive force would be a few tens of kilotons – a thousand times lower than in the 1980s.

This Russian first strike can be carried out at little risk for Russia, because the area of damage is limited to Germany, and a pretext is at hand, namely a ‘regrettable computer error in the automatic alarm system, which is unfortunately required since the US stationed the new missiles’. Russia could even immediately take responsibility and offer help and compensation. The hard-hit target areas (explosion areas and radioactive fallout drags) would make up a few percent of the area of Germany, with less than one percent of the population as victims of the attack. In view of this “minor” damage only to economic rival Germany and the now non-existent operational capability of US troops in Europe, the US government would possibly refrain from reacting militarily, because the Russian command system and the intercontinental ballistic missiles targeted at the USA would be fully functional and in a high state of alert.

The German-Russian relationship would be severely disrupted. Russia would have lost export customers for a while. But presumably the US would have permanently lost the role it had held as a European power since 1945, so Russia would have significantly and permanently increased its security. When Stalin annexed the area around Königsberg in 1945, he was reportedly interested in an ice-free Baltic Sea port. He probably never expected that one day this small enclave could play an existential military role for Russia.

The scenario described above must never happen. It can easily be prevented: The nuclear-weapon-free zone in Central Europe and in the European inland seas must be urgently established, starting with Germany immediately following Austria’s example (since 2017) and signing the UN Nuclear Ban Treaty. This is a sovereign German decision, regardless of the assessments and wishes of the US and NATO. The German signature of the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons is demanded by 80 percent of the German population. The territory of the former GDR – a third of today’s Germany – has been a nuclear-weapon-free zone since 1990, thanks to the Two-plus-Four Treaty. Now the rest of Germany must achieve the same status. Thus, there will be no more US targets for Russian missiles in Central Europe. The next step: NATO and Russia embedded in the pan-European peace order of the OSCE, and a ban on any future attempt to solve political problems in Europe through military force, with gradual demilitarization of the continent and meaningful reallocation of the saved funds for urgent civilian tasks.

Translated from German. Any errors the responsibility of END Info.

Hypersonic threat

From END Info 26 DOWNLOAD

Capture.JPG

According to Hypersonic Weapons: Background Issues for Congress, produced by the Congressional Research Service (accessed at: www.fas.org/sgp/crs/weapons/R45811.pdf):

The Department of Defense (DOD) is currently developing hypersonic weapons under the Navy’s Conventional Prompt Strike program, which is intended to provide the U.S. military with the ability to strike hardened or time-sensitive targets with conventional warheads, as well as through several Air Force, Army, and DARPA programs. Those who support these development efforts argue that hypersonic weapons could enhance deterrence, as well as provide the U.S. military with an ability to defeat capabilities such as advanced air and missile defense systems that form the foundation of U.S. competitors’ anti-access/area denial strategies. In recognition of this, the 2018 National Defense Strategy identifies hypersonic weapons as one of the key technologies “[ensuring the United States] will be able to fight and win the wars of the future.” Similarly, the House Armed Services Committee’s bipartisan Future of Defense Task Force Report notes that hypersonic weapons could present challenges to the United States in the years to come.

The report notes further that:

U.S. hypersonic weapons are to be conventionally armed. As a result, U.S. hypersonic weapons will likely require greater accuracy and will be more technically challenging to develop than nuclear-armed Chinese and Russian systems. Indeed, according to one expert, “a nuclear-armed glider would be effective if it were 10 or even 100 times less accurate [than a conventionally-armed glider]” due to nuclear blast effects.

The different branches of the US armed forces are developing their own hypersonic weapons systems:

U.S. Navy

In a June 2018 memorandum, DOD announced that the Navy would lead the development of a common glide vehicle for use across the services. The common glide vehicle is being adapted from a Mach 6 Army prototype warhead, the Alternate Re-Entry System, which was successfully tested in 2011 and 2017. Once development is complete, “Sandia National Laboratories, the designer of the original concept, then will build the common glide vehicles. ... Booster systems are being developed separately.”

The Navy’s Conventional Prompt Strike (CPS) is expected to pair the common glide vehicle with a booster system to create a common All Up Round (AUR) for use by both the Navy and Army ...

U.S. Army

The Army’s Long-Range Hypersonic Weapon program is expected to pair the common glide vehicle with the Navy’s booster system. The system is intended to have a range of over 1,725 miles and “provide the Army with a prototype strategic attack weapon system to defeat A2/AD capabilities, suppress adversary Long Range Fires, and engage other high payoff/time sensitive targets.”

U.S. Air Force

The AGM-183 Air-Launched Rapid Response Weapon is expected to leverage DARPA’s Tactical

Boost Glide technology to develop an air-launched hypersonic glide vehicle prototype capable of travelling at average speeds of between Mach 6.5 and Mach 8 at a range of approximately 1,000 miles. Despite testing delays due to technical challenges, ARRW successfully completed a “captive carry” test flight in June 2019; its first free-flight test failed in April 2021.

The development of these weapons is in part a response to similar developments in Russia and China, which the US and allies view as strategic competitor nations. The race to develop and deploy such weapons systems is part of the new ‘arms race’ which seeks to enhance existing military capabilities by introducing new technologies, robotics, artificial intelligence etc... into the battlefield.

The questions that remain unanswered are: when will these weapons be deployed and where will they be stationed?

According to a report (11 August 2021) on the Breaking Defense website:

The US Army is steadily progressing with its Long Range Hypersonic Weapon (LRHW) prototype, to the point the service plans to start training operations staff on ground-based equipment by mid October, says Bob Strider, deputy director of the Army Hypersonic Project Office.

“We are moving very rapidly toward getting this capability put in place,” he told the annual Space and Missile Defense Symposium on Tuesday. “We’re very, very confident that we’re going to meet our 2023 fielding date.”

The U.S. Navy and Air Force versions of these weapons will be in use wherever the Navy and Air Force deploy their ships and planes (the US has an extensive ‘boot print’) and as such the range of the weapons will not limit the scope of deployment as they will be carried by machines that themselves have significant ranges. The exact positioning of the ground-based hypersonic weapons by the US Army has not been revealed.

Various news reports on the operational requirements of the LRHW indicate that nearby airfields will be required to supply the equipment and military bases will be needed to house troops, conduct repairs etc...

The nature of the ground-based LRHW’s, their capabilities and the fact that they are intended to ‘meet the threat’ posed by Russia and China narrows down the likely field of deployment.

For example, with a reported range of 2,775km the LRHW could reach China from Guam. Likewise, if the LRHW was deployed in any part of Europe then Russia would be in range. It is worth noting that if LRHW was based in London, UK, for example, then it would be within comfortable range of Moscow, Russia, and the complex of command-and-control facilities in the area.

When these new weapon systems are deployed in Europe, it looks likely that they will be stationed in Germany or a neighbouring NATO member state (Poland, for example). It seems unlikely, but not impossible, that they will be stationed in the UK and whether or not the US is able to station them in Germany will depend to one degree or another on the outcome of the upcoming Federal elections.

Wherever these missiles are based in Europe, they are unlikely to increase security on the continent. More likely, the presence of such weapons will increase tensions further and lead to a deterioration of general security. There deployment will surely spark reciprocal deployments by Russia.

A further concern is addressed in more detail in Joachim Wernicke’s article on page 18. Although the LRHW’s are to ‘conventionally’ armed upon deployment, it appears that the missile technology is capable of ‘dual use’, which means that a conventional payload could be replaced with a nuclear payload. A similar situation exists with the Aegis Ashore missile systems: a fact we have pointed out on a number of occasions.

The European peace movements should be alert to the prospect of LRHW’s being stationed in Germany, Poland, Romania or elsewhere on the continent. We should be clear that any such stationing will degrade security and increase risk. Wherever possible, the alarm should be raised on this prospect and plans formulated to resist the deployment.

Reflections on Hiroshima

From END Info 26 DOWNLOAD

Tom Unterrainer

hiroshima-gettyimages-78964772.jpg

Tom Unterrainer delivered the following ‘reflection’ on behalf of the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament at Coventry Cathedral, UK, on Hiroshima Day 2021.

On October 21, 1945, the physicist Daniel Posin wrote to an esteemed colleague in the following terms:

The final total confirmation of your principle … should mark the beginning of an era of light; but we stand perturbed and seem to see ahead an impenetrable night …

The recipient of this letter was, of course, Albert Einstein.

How could Einstein have possibly known the destructive, genocidal consequences of his discoveries in advance?

Is the world in which such creative impulses are inhibited by fear a desirable one? I think not.

Instead, we should question why an era of light gave way to impenetrable night. Einstein’s last public act, in 1955, was to put his name to the ‘Russell-Einstein Manifesto’, which stated:

Remember your humanity, and forget the rest.

And continued:

If you can do so, the way lies open to a new Paradise; if you cannot, there lies before you the risk of universal death.

The light-seekers set an example for us all.

Take Setsuko Thurlow as an example. Thurlow was a 13-year-old schoolgirl when the United States dropped an atomic bomb on the Japanese city of Hiroshima, her home.

She recalls:

I still vividly remember that morning. At 8:15, I saw a blinding bluish-white flash from the window. I remember having the sensation of floating in the air … Then, suddenly, I felt hands touching my left shoulder, and heard a man saying: “Don’t give up! Keep pushing! I am trying to free you. See the light coming through that opening? Crawl towards it as quickly as you can.”

Setsuko survived the bombing. She moved towards the light. Not everyone who survived the initial blast, not everyone who – like her – emerged from the rubble of a city destroyed by the American bomb made it. She continues:

As I crawled out, the ruins were on fire. Most of my classmates in that building were burned to death alive. I saw all around me utter, unimaginable devastation.

In the decades that followed Setsuko Thurlow deployed her powerful testimony and a determination that such events should never occur again to build an international movement to ban nuclear weapons once and for all. The fruits of her efforts and those of thousands of others can be found in the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons, or ‘The Ban’.

‘The Ban’ is now in force. It is international law. The non-nuclear-armed world has come together to say “enough”. Yet the nuclear-armed states retain their nuclear machines of mass death. ‘The Ban’ opened the prospect of a “new era of light”, but the nuclear powers seem hellbent on perpetuating the “impenetrable night”.

Yet we continue with our work, for to do otherwise is to abandon hope for the world. Our task is obvious: the abolition of nuclear weapons, war and injustice.

The great American abolitionist John Brown once wrote that:

I cannot remember a night so dark as to have hindered the coming day.

Despite his forceful character and heroic efforts, Brown did not live to see the abolition of slavery in the United States. Will we live to see the abolition of nuclear weapons, war and injustice? Will the demands of “no more Hiroshima’s, no more Nagasaki’s” be heard in our lifetimes?

The night is, after all, pretty dark and it is getting darker.

When the world faces the triple threats of climate catastrophe, pandemic and nuclear dangers you would hope to see increased international cooperation and solidarity. Instead, a carrier strike group is making its way from these shores to the other side of the world. Whether this voyage of provocation results in acute embarrassment or acute danger largely relies on the tolerance of others.

When international laws are broken and additional billions of pounds are expended on an increased nuclear warhead stockpile, sharp questions must be raised.

When poverty and inequality stalk the land, the world is re-arming: developing new nuclear weapons, new killer drones, automatic death machines and much else. There is a new arms race when the race that really matters – to vaccinate the world, to end poverty, eradicate inequality – has hardly begun.

In all this darkness, we must keep pointing and moving towards the light. In these efforts, we are not alone. We number in the millions. We exist in every village, town and city in every corner of the world.

With John Brown, surely we cannot remember a night so dark as to have hindered the coming day.

German elections: what prospects for peace and disarmament?

From END Info 26 DOWNLOAD

German voters go to the polls on Sunday, 26 September. The outcome of this election will determine not only who will replace Angela Merkel as German Chancellor, but the political composition of the Bundestag. Merkel is standing down from office after almost sixteen years, a period during which Germany has maintained and extended its position as Europe’s most influential nation. Consequently, Germany is an important voice in international affairs.

Polling in the first week of September suggests that Merkel’s party, the Christian Democratic Union (CDU), will not maintain control of the Chancellory. The polling may or may not change. The German electoral system has resulted in broad representation in the Bundestag. However, the much prized ‘stability’ of the German system has meant that the Chancellor comes from the party with the largest vote share: this will likely mean either the CDU or Social Democratic Party (SDP).

With a single party unlikely to achieve a basic majority of votes, a coalition government will be formed again. The political composition and dynamics of such a coalition is therefore important for determining the dimensions of future foreign, defence and security policy. If, for example, either the Green Party or Left Party were to join a coalition, what impact might this have? It is not possible to guess, but a brief survey of the stated positions of the main contending parties may provide some clues.

According to the ‘Alliance for Securing Democracy’, a US organisation with links to the security services and government:

The four centrist parties—CDU/CSU, FDP, Greens, and SPD—all have a strong commitment to the European and transatlantic orientation of German foreign policy. Despite varying policies, the parties all advocate for further European integration through the European Union (EU) and consider the transatlantic relationship and its defense alliance NATO to be integral to German foreign and defense policy. In contrast, the [Left] calls on the EU to make major policy changes and structural reforms, while the AfD [right-wing] demands a renationalization of European politics. Furthermore, the AfD calls for NATO to limit itself to defense measures and refrain from deployments outside member countries. The [Left] considers NATO a relic of the Cold War and advocates for a new collective security alliance that includes Russia.

So in terms of the basic approach to the ‘broad stroke’ foreign policy agenda, the main parties look likely to continue as before. It is unlikely that Alternative für Deutschland (AfD) will be invited to join a coalition but it is not beyond the realms of possibility that the Left might achieve some influence. What might be achieved if they get the opportunity?

German policy towards Russia and China has been more nuanced than in the USA and UK. With regards to Russia, a continual process of engagement has been balanced with the ‘containment’ approach pursued by NATO. The Left calls for further engagement whilst the Greens call for maintaining EU sanctions. The ‘Nord Stream 2’ gas pipeline is an issue where the parties differentiate themselves, with the Greens calling for an immediate end to the scheme in contrast to the other parties. Whatever the exact approach to Russia, those interested in peace and security will not want to see a deterioration in relations.

The CDU, Greens, SPD and others parties of the ‘centre’ call for a coordinated European approach to China. At the same time, the Greens and CDU characterise China as having ‘authoritarian, hegemonic aspirations’, as wanting to ‘divide Europe’ and call for a ‘transatlantic’ approach.

The American Institute for Contemporary German Studies argues that the question of China is not a major concern for the German public. 53% of German’s see China’s growing influence as either ‘neutral’ (43%) or ‘positive’ (10%). The same poll indicates that 82% think that Germany should remain ‘neutral’ in “the case of a new US-Chinese cold war”. Will public opinion guide the new government or will existing alliances and demands determine Germany’s course? If the outcome of the election looks unlikely to usher in a new, much less confrontational and completely independent, approach, it should be hoped that some constructive nuance and partial independence is maintained.

How will the new government approach the question of the ‘militarisation of Europe’? The existing CDU/SDP coalition has failed to generate an overall strategic approach to defence questions but has been a key participant in the steady militarisation of the EU. Writing on the European Council on Foreign Relations website, Ulrike Franke speculates on what a ‘Black-Green’ (CDU-Green) coalition might produce in terms of defence policy. She writes:

[H]ow could a Black-Green coalition, of all things, improve this situation? After all, the Greens partly developed out of the peace movement of the 1970s, and they oppose most of the CDU’s views on military and defence. The Greens want to introduce highly restrictive arms export rules, and are critical of what they see as the “militarisation” of the European Union.

There are three reasons to be optimistic. Firstly, the bar is low. It would be difficult for a new coalition to do worse than the current one. For the last few years, the CDU/CSU and its current coalition partner, the Social Democratic Party, have been at loggerheads with each other, especially over defence questions.

Whilst there is room for optimism for those keen to see greater European military integration and spending, those who oppose such developments have fewer options. It seems that only the Left Party, which has consistently opposed European militarisation and which has used its platform in both the Bundestag and European Parliament to coordinate opposition, provides hope.

Although Germany is not itself nuclear-armed, the question of nuclear weapons is a live public issue in German politics. The questions of ‘nuclear sharing’ and the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW) are issues of debate. Germany hosts US nuclear weapons and under ‘sharing’ agreements the German armed forces are obliged to ‘deliver’ these weapons upon request. This arrangement is deeply contentious in the ranks of the SDP and in all political organisations to the left of it. Despite voices within the SDP being opposed to the continuation of this arrangement, the party itself has no settled view on the matter. Both the Greens and the Left are pledged to ending nuclear sharing as soon as possible. Such a move will be popular with the German public (see page 13). However, as Steven Pifer reports in a recent paper for the Brookings Institute (Germany’s Upcoming Election and the Future of Nuclear Sharing):

[Some] argue that the Greens would not want to cause problems with NATO; while maintaining the aspirational goal of withdrawal of US nuclear weapons, they would be prepared to “stomach” continued nuclear sharing for the time being.

The 2009 coalition agreement between the CDU/CSU and FDP offers a warning. Guido Westerwelle, then leader of the FDP who went on to become German Foreign Minister, secured the following clause in the agreement:

[The German government] will work to support the conclusion of new disarmament and arms control agreements internationally ... In this context and in the course of developing a strategic concept for NATO, we will work in the alliance and with our American allies to ensure that the nuclear weapons remaining in Germany are withdrawn.

No progress was made towards the goal of withdrawing US nuclear weapons following this agreement. What stopped the progress? Westerwelle encountered very strong opposition within NATO. It looks unlikely that progress will be made in the future without the question of NATO being confronted in a serious fashion.

Both the Greens and the Left are pledged to Germany signing and ratifying the TPNW. The significance of Europe’s ‘leading nation’ taking such a move would be enormous. Writing a pledge to join the TPNW into any coalition agreement will be a massive step forward. However, Germany is likely to meet sharp resistance within NATO for any such move. NATO and Germany’s membership of it remains a key issue for peace and disarmament in Europe.

Scottish independence and the future of Trident

From END Info 26 DOWNLOAD

FLEET-20210614-AP0017-093.jpg

According to reports in the Financial Times (1 September 2021), the British government has “drawn up secret contingency plans to move its Trident nuclear submarine bases from Scotland to the US or France in the event of Scottish independence.”

The background to the formulation of these plans is that the Scottish National Party remains committed to pursuing independence; opposes nuclear weapons and was recently re-elected to head the devolved government with a strong mandate. In short, it is not out of the question that the people of Scotland will have the opportunity to vote again for independence and it seems possible that a majority will vote in favour.

Whatever your specific thoughts on independence, two things are clear: firstly, that the London government of Boris Johnson is deeply unattractive, reactionary and has pursued policies against the will of the majority of Scottish voters and to their material detriment; secondly, that an independent Scotland would pitch Britain’s nuclear weapons systems into crisis.

Writing in The National newspaper (6 September 2021), the SNP’s Stewart McDonald comments:

Negotiating Trident’s removal will be one of the most important tasks a newly independent Scotland will face, and capitals across Europe – indeed the world – will be looking to Edinburgh for assurance that we will be a reliable and trustworthy partner in this and in future international negotiations.

How we handle Trident’s removal will be our first big test on the international stage.

Building and maintaining strong international relationships is about more than stability, shared values and shared interests. It also relies on each state recognising and respecting the national interests of other states, even when they might diverge from their own.

Submarines armed with the UK’s nuclear weapons are based at the Faslane naval base at HMNB Clyde, near Glasgow, Scotland. The base is also home to a number of nuclear-powered but conventionally armed ‘hunter killer’ submarines, which are used to escort the nuclear armed, Trident subs. Glasgow itself is Scotland’s most populated city and locals are very well informed about the fact that their city is itself a potential target for nuclear attack.

The FT article raises possibilities for alternative arrangements for Trident should Scotland become an independent state:

The first [option] would be to relocate the bases elsewhere on the British Isles, with the Royal Navy’s Devonport base cited as the most likely location to replace Faslane...

The second option would be to move the UK’s nuclear bases to an allied country such as the US, with one defence expert citing Kings Bay, Georgia, the base for the US Navy’s Atlantic fleet of Trident submarines. Officials also examined moving the UK’s submarine base to Île Longue in Brittany, France.

The third option is to negotiate a new British Overseas Territory within an independent Scottish state that would contain the Faslane and Coulport bases, dubbed by one insider as a “Nuclear Gibraltar”.

The late John Ainslie, of Scottish CND, provides an indispensable guide for the questions raised by the FT and the SNP’s commitment to removing nuclear weapons from Scotland, in his 2013 report Trident: Nowhere to Go. Ainslie’s report makes clear that incredible barriers exist to the relocation of Trident to an alternative location in the British Isles. He writes:

50 years ago the [Ministry of Defence] drew up a list of possible locations for Polaris [the old nuclear missile system], including sites in England and Wales. Today these papers will be dusted off. Officials may also revive an option that was raised in 1981 - basing the UK Trident fleet in the United States. A second overseas possibility would be Ile Longue in France. Building a floating support ship might be a further option.

There were three English sites on the Polaris shortlist. One was Portland, near Weymouth. This was dismissed because there was no suitable location for a nuclear warhead depot nearby. Today there are houses adjacent to the required area. The site was the venue for the sailing events in the 2012 Olympics.

A second alternative was Devonport. In 1963 the MOD considered transforming part of the Cornish shore, opposite the dockyard, into a nuclear weapons’ store. A modern equivalent would be far larger. It would be adjacent to a residential estate as well as being close to the city of Plymouth. It is inconceivable that this would be permitted.

The third location was Falmouth. The proposed submarine base would be on National Trust land close to St Just in Roseland. Acquiring this would be very difficult. The warhead depot would be North of Falmouth. Two villages would be so close to the depot that they would have to be abandoned. In 1963 the MOD concluded that the costs of acquiring and developing this site for Polaris would be so great that the project wasn’t feasible. A Trident depot would be much larger and even less viable ...

An existing nuclear site that might be considered is Barrow in Furness, where the submarines are built. This might be suitable if the Navy only deploys Trident when there is a full moon and a high tide. Otherwise it is a non-starter. Walney Channel is too shallow. The Barrow option was not seriously considered in 1963.

The one Welsh location on the old shortlist was Milford Haven. Siting Polaris here would have resulted in the closure of one oil refinery. Introducing Trident in this estuary today would end four major petrochemical facilities and cut off one of Britain’s main sources of gas. The grounds for dismissing Milford Haven, as with all the other sites, are even stronger today than they were fifty years ago.

In 1963 each of these options was rejected.

So it would seem that the first option listed by the FT and considered in the “secret contingency plans” looks like a complete non-starter.

What of option 2? What the British government still fancifully refers to as an “independent nuclear deterrent” is completely dependent on US nuclear operations. The FT refers to Kings Bay in Georgia, US, as being the base for the US Navy’s Atlantic fleet, but fails to mention that this naval base is also the first stop for subs in Britain’s nuclear submarine fleet on each voyages. As Commander Robert Forsyth points out is his book, Why Trident? (Spokesman, 2020):

When the government says UK Trident is ‘Independent’ they are being very economical with the facts. Whilst it is correct to say that RN missiles do not require specific US aid for targetting, launch or guidance in flight, with the notable exception of supply of missiles in the first case, the UK’s deep dependency on US technical and political support means that the US does have the tools to inhibit or frustrate launch if it so wished ...

The UK Parliament’s Defence Select Committee detailed report of UK dependency on US support shows that the level of dependency is significantly higher than the Government would lead the public to believe. Not included in the report is the fact that the UK is designing and building (with US assistance) a common 12 missile module for both USN and RN Trident successor submarines.

Britain’s ‘independent nuclear deterrent’ is wholly reliant on US missile capabilities, repair and renewal facilities. Not so ‘independent’. Relocating the fleet to the US would expose this fantasy once and for all. For this reason alone, the British government may be reluctant to pursue such an option. If such a relocation did take place, how would the development, renewal and transit of nuclear warheads from Britain to the US function? Major obstacles exist to such an option, even though it may be entirely logical and consistent with reality.

What of relocating the fleet to France? Any such move would be a major political humiliation for the British government and would doubtless meet fierce resistance from the French peace movement.

The ‘third option’ is, in fact, no option at all. A follow-up report in the FT makes clear that a future independent Scotland would not accept the creation of a ‘British Overseas Territory’ at the existing base:

“There is just not a snowball’s chance in hell of nuclear weapons being based here for any longer than is necessary,” said one senior SNP member familiar with the party leadership’s thinking on defence issues.

“It will become obvious to [UK policymakers] that madcap ideas like treaty ports from 100 years ago in Ireland will not be accepted and are unworkable for any state wanting to credibly operate a strategic nuclear deterrent,” the senior party member said.

Britain’s nuclear weapons may well have ‘nowhere to go’ in the event of Scottish independence. Such a possibility should cheer the hearts of all nuclear disarmers. The prospect of the British government going cap-in-hand to the US or France for assistance reveals the fragile nature of the nuclear infrastructure in the UK. John Ainslie struck an appropriately optimistic tone when he wrote:

Because there is no viable alternative site for Trident, Scottish independence could result in there being no nuclear weapons in Britain. This would be welcomed by all those around the world who seek disarmament, and it could encourage other countries to follow suit. A Scotland which votes for independence and then sustains a clear policy of banning these Weapons of Mass Destruction will also to set an example to the world.