Russia’s ‘Nuclear Deterrence Fundamentals 2020’

From END Info 20

Johnson’s Russia List (JRL) recently highlighted an important statement of Russia’s new “Basic Principles of State Policy of the Russian Federation on Nuclear Policy”. This document was released by Moscow in June 2020 and, as the analysis points out, such publication - including an easily accessible English translation - marks a departure from previous years.

JRL asks: “One immediate question is whether the idea of using nuclear weapons in a regional conflict as part of an ‘escalation for de-escalation’ strategy still exists in Russia’s military planning.” The answer? “Yes, and no: the West and Russia have different interpretations of this central concept ... The West tends to associate the notion with the threat of, say, attacking the Baltic states, but Russia sees it as nuclear-based coercion that prevents NATO from defending these allies ... Meanwhile, there are no credible signs that Russia is planning to attack the Baltics, especially with any hint of nuclear weapons, which would open direct conflict with NATO.”

The open publication of Russia’s nuclear posture should serve to clarify any confusion about Russia’s intentions with regard to this strategy, which was adopted in response to the “Serbian scenario” at the end of the 1990s, when NATO intervened directly in Europe.

The bad news from this document is that Russia has codified its nuclear posture response to the changing nuclear landscape in Europe by issuing a number of “red lines” and a lower threshold for nuclear use. For instance, “the policy says that only ‘reliable’ information ... is needed about the launch of any ballistic missile toward Russia for there to be a potential response. This undermines the future deployment of U.S. intermediate-range missiles in Europe and missiles connected with the Aegis offshore missile defence system - all of which Russia officially calls offensive infrastructure.”

This posture is a clear response to Trump’s sabotage of the INF Treaty and threats to station a new generation of nuclear weapons in Europe. ‘Every action has a reaction’ and Trump’s bonfire of treaties and international norms has made the world a much more dangerous place.

Tromsø says ‘Nei’ to US sub base, govn pushes ahead

From END Info 20

Local politicians in Tromsø, Northern Norway, have expressed their opposition to plans to re-open a mothballed base in the area to house US submarines. The base was decommissioned by the Norwegian navy in 2009, but now the US Navy wishes to make a deal to allow use of the Olavsvern base.

US subs have already visited the base, including the USS Seawolf fast attack vessel in August this year. It is thought the both US and NATO subs will sail from the base in the near future.

The position of the Olavsvern base in the Arctic region is strategically important to the US and NATO, which is fixated on ‘responding to’ perceived Russian threats in the region. The opening of a permanent NATO base in the area is likely to do little more than increase already heightened tensions.

In response to opposition from the local council, the Norwegian government responded along the lines that “Tromsø cannot independently leave NATO”! Why not, we ask in return?

The story of the Olavsvern base illustrates the degree to which international relations have deteriorated and the degree to which the western military alliance is once again adopting a ‘Cold War’ mentality.

After the end of the ‘Cold War’, the Norwegian military lost interest in the base. It served no purpose and cost a great deal of money to keep operational. Following logic, they sold it. Strangely enough, the Norwegian version of ebay was used and one lucky buyer picked it up for $5 million. The base later changed hands and the current owners envisaged using it for logistics and repair support for Norway’s enormous oil industry. It looks like these plans are now on hold.

Will the US and NATO allies be stationing nuclear-armed submarines at the base? How often will the base be used? What risks are posed to nearby residents? What risks are posed more widely? Does the US envisage engaging Russian submarines and other naval vessels or is the base just a ‘show of force’ (a dangerous one)?

Tromsø was right to say ‘Nei’ to the plans and we join their call of opposition.

New US ‘Nuclear Sea-Launched Cruise Missile’

From END Info 20

Dr Robert Soofer, US Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defence for Nuclear and Missile Defense Policy announced a new generation of “nuclear sea-launched cruise missiles” during a meeting at the Mitchell Institute for Aerospace Studies in early September. Soofer characterised the announcement as a “response to Russia’s tactical nuclear weapons.”

download.jpg

In fact, such a development is entirely in line with strategy embedded in the US’s last Nuclear Posture Review and fits with the overall posture of aggression adopted against Russia and China.

Such developments will not have escaped the attention of those states characterised as “strategic rivals” or “competitors” in various US policy documents and will surely lead to reciprocal technology developments and deployment.

END Info was alerted to the prospect of a new generation of sea-launched missiles earlier this year by Dr Joachim Wernicke, a Berlin-based analyst and translator of the German edition of Cmdr Rob Greeen’s Security without Nuclear Deterrence. In his analysis of such a development, Dr Wernicke raised the prospect that such systems could be deployed in the seas close to Europe as an alternative to a new generation of land-based nuclear -capable intermediate-range missiles. This prospect now looks all the more likely.

Combined with announcements of the W76-2 tactical nuclear warhead, the overall effect is to lower the ‘nuclear threshold’ once more. What the nuclear-armed states refer to as ‘strategic flexibility’ actually amounts to risk multiplication.

We will remain alert to the prospect of these weapons being deployed outside of US territorial waters.

The Belmarsh Tribunal

The ‘Progressive International’, an organisation of activists, artists, intellectuals and others, has convened The Belmarsh Tribunal to “to put the United States government on trial for its crimes of the twenty first century – from atrocities in Iraq to torture at Guantánamo Bay to the CIA‘s illegal surveillance program – and draw attention to the extradition case of Julian Assange for revealing them.”

https___cdn.evbuc.com_images_112997189_470165261881_1_original.jpg

Named after the prison in which Julian Assange is being held, this new tribunal invokes the legacy of the International War Crimes Tribunal founded by Bertrand Russell in response to the US’s actions in Vietnam. The Bertrand Russell Peace Foundation wrote to Yannis Varoufakis and Srecko Horvat from the Progressive International as follows:

Dear Yannis, Dear Srecko, We were encouraged to hear of your timely initiative in convening the Belmarsh Tribunal. In Russell’s words about the Vietnam War Crimes Tribunal, it is urgently necessary to ‘prevent the crime of silence’ surrounding Julian Assange and the extradition proceedings to which he is subject. We wish you well in your endeavours, and please let us know if we can assist.

With greetings from England!

Tony Simpson, Tom Unterrainer and Tamara Coates

Don't Extradite Assange

From END Info 20

“[I]t is our responsibility to stand by a true journalist whose sheer courage ought to be inspiration to all of us who still believe that freedom is possible. I salute him.” John Pilger

20200716_103755__01-1200x600.jpg

The WikiLeaks founder, journalist Julian Assange, sits in Belmarsh Prison awaiting his fate. Will he be extradited to the United States, or will he be freed? The campaign that has been waged against Julian is in response to his heroic work in exposing the recent crimes of American imperialism and revealing the intrigue at the heart of power diplomacy. In these efforts, WikiLeaks and Julian were assisted by equally heroic whistle-blowers like Edward Snowden and Chelsea Manning: people in the ‘heart of the machine’ who saw the evil at work and decided to expose it to the world. As John Pilger reports (see www.johnpilger.com), there has been a determined effort to ‘get’ Julian Assange. He writes: ‘In 2008, a top secret US State Department report described in detail how the United States would combat this new moral threat. A secretly-directed personal smear campaign against Julian Assange would lead to "exposure [and] criminal prosecution". The aim was to silence and criminalise WikiLeaks and its founder. Page after page revealed a coming war on a single human being and on the very principle of freedom of speech and freedom of thought, and democracy. The imperial shock troops would be those who called themselves journalists: the big hitters of the so-called mainstream, especially the "liberals" who mark and patrol the perimeters of dissent. And that is what happened. I have been a reporter for more than 50 years and I have never known a smear campaign like it: the fabricated character assassination of a man who refused to join the club: who believed journalism was a service to the public, never to those above.’ If the worst happens and Julian Assange is extradited to the USA, then a serious breach of justice will be done. Journalism will have been criminalised and all our freedoms will be undermined.

The Bomb has been banned!

From END Info 20

As END Info 20 goes to press, the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW) has secured fifty ratifications and will come ‘into force’ on 22 January 2021. This historic event is the result of consistent and heroic efforts on the part of the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons (ICAN) and reflects growing international concern about nuclear tensions.

122826579_4289430477740505_7770958323887058842_o.jpg

Meanwhile, the United States is engaged in desperate measures to undermine the TPNW. The Associated Press has obtained a copy of a letter sent by the US to TPNW signatories which claims that the treaty “turns back the clock on verification and disarmament and is dangerous ... Although we recognize your sovereign right to ratify or accede to the ... [TPNW] we believe that you have made a strategic error and should withdraw your instrument of ratification or accession”.

Responding to the letter, Beatrice Fihn from ICAN characterised such claims as “straightforward lies, to be frank.” The US pitches its objection around the TPNW being a threat to the NPT. This is not only false, given that the NPT explicitly calls for further measures to advance complete nuclear disarmament, but is a bit rich coming from a nuclear armed state that has done little to advance work on the NPT and which has systematically undermined a host of other global nuclear treaties.

This latest action by the US is part of an ongoing effort by the nuclear armed states to undermine the TPNW and to coerce non-nuclear armed states into rejecting the treaty. Perhaps the most significant obstacles have been the actions of the US, UK and NATO allies. The effects of the ‘NATO factor’ can be seen in the fact that the only European states that have ratified the TPNW to date are all non-NATO members. This poses questons about the future direction of the campaign around the TPNW and suggests that a focus on NATO along with consideration of complementary initiatives might be appropriate.

Meanwhile, the TPNW is a reality. The existing, truly inspiring, efforts to achieve ratification will surely continue. In a number of countries there are lively efforts to win further support. Likewise, a planned conference of TPNW ‘ratifiers’ which looks set to take place in Austria, will put additional pressure on those states that have not already ratified the treaty. In addition, such a conference will be an important platform for exposing the dangers of nuclear tensions, nuclear weapons and the nuclear risks we face.

The TPNW will be an essential political tool for campaigners dealing with political parties that present themselves as ‘defenders and promoters of human rights and international law’, but who in contradiction to their professed policies maintain a commitment to weapons of mass murder and attempt to ignore this global treaty.

The TPNW is here. The bomb has been banned. Now it’s up to the peace movements across the world to promote, extend and mobilise to ensure that the TPNW truly comes “into force”. Much work to do in 2021, but the TPNW is a powerful and essential tool in our work for a nuclear free world.

Iran and the nuclear deal

As tensions continue around the Iran nuclear deal, two recent decisions return the spotlight to Iran and the nuclear weapon question in the Middle East.

trump-iran-deal.jpg

First, the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) blocked attempts by the US to ‘snapback’ all sanctions against Iran that were lifted following agreement of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPoA) – or, Iran Deal – in 2015.

The ‘E3′ members of the JCPoA – France, Germany and the United Kingdom – were amongst those who opposed the attempt. They noted in a public statement “that the US ceased to be a participant to the JCPoA following their withdrawal from the deal on 8 May, 2018 … We cannot therefore support this action which is incompatible with our current efforts to support the JCPoA.”

In response, a US envoy accused the UNSC of “standing in the company of terrorists”.

Second, Iran has granted the International Atomic Energy Agency access to two sites which the US and Israeli governments claim are connected to secret nuclear material and activity. Permission to access these sites is a major step forward following events at the start of 2020 and more recent incidents. The assassination of Major General Qasem Soleimani in Baghdad, January 2020, emphasised that the Trump administration regards Iran as a target and that it is prepared to take reckless actions.

The situation could easily have spiralled out of control if not for a degree of political and military restraint on the part of the Iranian government. Some commentators warned that this event might trigger the start of a ‘nuclear arms race’ in the Middle East.

The Iranian government are fully aware that both Iraq and Libya renounced their nuclear weapons programmes and that following this, both countries faced onslaught from the US military. The twisted ‘logic’ of nuclear deterrence suggests that possession of a nuclear weapons capability ensures against such a prospect. Substantiation for such a risk was provided by the Iranian government itself, when two days after the killing it announced that it would no longer abide by any of the constraints or limitations on nuclear enrichment contained in the JCPoA. The US, which had withdrawn from the JCPoA alleging Iranian breaches despite confirmation from IAEA inspectors that Iran was abiding by the rules, intensified lobbying for a sanctions ‘snapback’ from this point.

Despite US pressure, other parties to the JCPoA continued to work within the framework of the agreement. Following Iran’s statement of intent, the E3 triggered a ‘dispute resolution mechanism’ which, if not for ongoing diplomatic flexibility on the part of the Iranians, could have forced the complete collapse of the JCPoA. Some analysts have suggested that this was the intent of at least one E3 leader, UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson. However, the JCPoA framework has not collapsed and Iran continues to engage. For serious progress to be made and for the JCPoA to endure, other parties will have to offer Iran serious incentives rather than threats of tightening sanctions or further aggression.

Events such as those at the Natanz nuclear facility in July this year will not have bolstered confidence in a diplomatic solution. It was initially feared that the explosion at the facility resulted from a missile strike, but more recently Iranian officials pinpointed the cause as an act of sabotage. The source and inspiration of the sabotage has not yet been revealed. Whilst we should hope that progress is maintained and support all diplomatic efforts to avert the breakdown of the JCPoA, we should remain alert to the risks of further unilateral action by the United States.

The US ‘envoy’ who ‘undiplomatically’ characterised the United Nations Security Council of standing with terrorists is none other than Elliott Abrams, ‘U.S. special envoy to Iran’. Abrams was characterised in The Nation magazine as having a career “literally built on the defense of mass murder and genocide and his willingness to lie on behalf of those who carried it out and smear the reputations of anyone who sought to try and stop or expose it.” This quote refers directly to Abrams’ dealings in Central America in the 1980s. That’s a deeply concerning résumé for someone tasked with representing US interests anywhere, let alone in Iran, and points to the aggressive posture adopted by the US.

The weeks running up to the US Presidential election will likely see Trump making unpredictable and potentially disastrous decisions in an attempt to distract from the multiple failures of his government and to mobilise opinion behind him. We should not discount the possibility that one such decision could include military action. If it does, then the fact that Iran is already in the cross-hairs should put the peace and anti-war movements on the alert.

First published on the CND website www.cnduk.org

Nuclear disarmament on the agenda!

As the number of states ratifying the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW) edges ever closer to the ‘magic number’ of 50, it looks certain that a ‘global ban’ of nuclear weapons will come ‘into force’ early in 2021. Once the Treaty passes this threshold, the nuclear-armed states and other states, ‘non-nuclear’ NATO members for instance, will have to decide whether or not to continue ignoring the TPNW or if they’ll take their obligations as ‘law-abiding’ states seriously. If, as looks likely, the nuclear-armed states and allies continue on their destructive path then the international peace movement must vigorously respond, as they undoubtedly will. To their credit, the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons (ICAN) has worked tirelessly to achieve a situation where we not only have an international treaty with growing support but an international shift in perception where whatever ‘legitimacy’ nuclear weapons still enjoy has received a massive dent. ICAN has coordinated the following ‘open letter’ addressing the current situation and what must now be done.

* * *

Fifty-six former presidents, prime ministers, foreign ministers and defence ministers from 20 NATO member states, as well as Japan and South Korea, have just issued an open letter calling on current leaders to join the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons:

The coronavirus pandemic has starkly demonstrated the urgent need for greater international cooperation to address all major threats to the health and welfare of humankind. Paramount among them is the threat of nuclear war. The risk of a nuclear weapon detonation today — whether by accident, miscalculation or design — appears to be increasing, with the recent deployment of new types of nuclear weapons, the abandonment of longstanding arms control agreements, and the very real danger of cyber-attacks on nuclear infrastructure. Let us heed the warnings of scientists, doctors and other experts. We must not sleepwalk into a crisis of even greater proportions than the one we have experienced this year. It is not difficult to foresee how the bellicose rhetoric and poor judgment of leaders in nuclear-armed nations might result in a calamity affecting all nations and peoples. As past leaders, foreign ministers and defence ministers of Albania, Belgium, Canada, Croatia, the Czech Republic, Denmark, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Italy, Japan, Latvia, the Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Slovenia, South Korea, Spain and Turkey — all countries that claim protection from an ally’s nuclear weapons — we appeal to current leaders to advance disarmament before it is too late. An obvious starting point for the leaders of our own countries would be to declare without qualification that nuclear weapons serve no legitimate military or strategic purpose in light of the catastrophic human and environmental consequences of their use. In other words, our countries should reject any role for nuclear weapons in our defence. By claiming protection from nuclear weapons, we are promoting the dangerous and misguided belief that nuclear weapons enhance security. Rather than enabling progress towards a world free of nuclear weapons, we are impeding it and perpetuating nuclear dangers — all for fear of upsetting our allies who cling to these weapons of mass destruction. But friends can and must speak up when friends engage in reckless behaviour that puts their lives and ours in peril. Without doubt, a new nuclear arms race is under way, and a race for disarmament is urgently needed. It is time to bring the era of reliance on nuclear weapons to a permanent end. In 2017, 122 countries took a courageous but long-overdue step in that direction by adopting the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons — a landmark global accord that places nuclear weapons on the same legal footing as chemical and biological weapons and establishes a framework to eliminate them verifiably and irreversibly. Soon it will become binding international law. To date, our countries have opted not to join the global majority in supporting this treaty. But our leaders should reconsider their positions. We cannot afford to dither in the face of this existential threat to humanity. We must show courage and boldness — and join the treaty. As states parties, we could remain in alliances with nuclear-armed states, as nothing in the treaty itself nor in our respective defence pacts precludes that. But we would be legally bound never under any circumstances to assist or encourage our allies to use, threaten to use or possess nuclear weapons. Given the very broad popular support in our countries for disarmament, this would be an uncontroversial and much-lauded move. The prohibition treaty is an important reinforcement to the half-century-old Non-Proliferation Treaty, which, though remarkably successful in curbing the spread of nuclear weapons to more countries, has failed to establish a universal taboo against the possession of nuclear weapons. The five nuclear-armed nations that had nuclear weapons at the time of the NPT’s negotiation — the United States, Russia, Britain, France and China — apparently view it as a licence to retain their nuclear forces in perpetuity. Instead of disarming, they are investing heavily in upgrades to their arsenals, with plans to retain them for many decades to come. This is patently unacceptable. The prohibition treaty adopted in 2017 can help end decades of paralysis in disarmament. It is a beacon of hope in a time of darkness. It enables countries to subscribe to the highest available multilateral norm against nuclear weapons and build international pressure for action. As its preamble recognizes, the effects of nuclear weapons “transcend national borders, pose grave implications for human survival, the environment, socioeconomic development, the global economy, food security and the health of current and future generations, and have a disproportionate impact on women and girls, including as a result of ionizing radiation”. With close to 14,000 nuclear weapons located at dozens of sites across the globe and on submarines patrolling the oceans at all times, the capacity for destruction is beyond our imagination. All responsible leaders must act now to ensure that the horrors of 1945 are never repeated. Sooner or later, our luck will run out — unless we act. The nuclear weapon ban treaty provides the foundation for a more secure world, free from this ultimate menace. We must embrace it now and work to bring others on board. There is no cure for a nuclear war. Prevention is our only option.

Signed by:

Lloyd Axworthy, Former Minister of Foreign Affairs of Canada

Ban Ki-moon, Former Secretary-General of the United Nations and Minister of Foreign Affairs of South Korea

Jean-Jacques Blais, Former Minister of National Defence of Canada

Kjell Magne Bondevik, Former Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs of Norway and 53 others.

See www.icanw.org for more information.

U.S.S. Britain: B-52s over Europe

“B-52s are back at RAF Fairford, and will be operating across the theater in what will be a very active deployment. Our ability to quickly respond and assure allies and partners rests upon the fact that we are able to deploy our B-52s at a moment’s notice,” announced Gen. Jeff Harrigian, U.S. Air Forces in Europe and Air Forces Africa commander. He continued: “Their presence here helps build trust with our NATO allies and partner nations and affords us new opportunities to train together through a variety of scenarios.”

bombs-US-Air-Force-training-exercise-B-52.jpg

Six B-52s landed at Fairford airbase in the UK at the end of August for what has been described as a ‘routine training mission’. General Harrigian and NATO allies might want to paint this mission as merely ‘routine’, reality tells us a different story.

For a start, the announcement that B-52s were “back at Fairford” tells you that they haven’t been there for some time. We know that the B-52s flew missions from this air-base during the invasion of Iraq and in earlier confrontations. After more than fifteen years, why return now?

Second, B-52s are not simple and straightforward aircraft. Hans Kristensen from the Federation of American Scientists identified two of the bombers deployed to Fairford as being nuclear capable. Were these aircraft carrying nuclear weapons when they landed? Were they carrying them when they took off again? What, exactly, was the intention of the US and NATO in deploying such aircraft with such a capability to Europe at the present moment?

Thirdly, the ‘training mission’ in which the B-52s were apparently engaged included flying over each and every NATO member state in Europe. This was not ‘training’, this was a show of force. Worse, the aircraft then went on to fly over Ukraine - not a NATO member-state - and made close approaches to the Russian border (20km away, according to some reports).

Rather than a ‘training mission’, we have seen an effort from the US and NATO to further increase nuclear tensions in Europe. Great Britain was used as a staging-post for this aggressive and ultimately dangerous show of nuclear force. Are we returning to the days when the UK was little more than a United States Ship off the coast of Europe?

Operation “Allied Sky”, as NATO named the stunt, was designed to show ‘adversaries’ - real and imagined - that should it choose to do so, the ‘Alliance’ is more than capable to delivering genocidal death from the skies.

To take such a course of action during ongoing developments in Belarus and ongoing tensions in Ukraine is completely unacceptable. We already know that the US views the whole of Europe as a ‘nuclear battleground’. In return, we say: make Europe a nuclear-weapons-free zone.